With-profits insurance
This page applies the variable fee approach to with-profits insurance. It covers the pooled fund, guarantee and bonuses, cash flow projection, guarantee cost and a market fall.
Product
What is with-profits insurance?
A with-profits policy, also called a participating policy, shares in the profits of a large fund that the insurer invests for all its with-profits policyholders. This page calls that fund the pool.
This example is a conventional UK-style with-profits savings policy with a single premium, a guaranteed amount on death or at maturity, yearly bonuses and a 90/10 profit split. Participating products exist in many markets, often as whole-life cover or with a guaranteed interest rate instead of a guaranteed amount. Their guarantees and profit-sharing rules differ, and in some countries the law sets a minimum share for policyholders.
The insurer tracks each policy's share of the pool, which is called the asset share. It grows with the pool's return, minus costs and a charge for the guarantee. Unlike a unit-linked policy, there is no unit price for the policyholder to follow.
The policy also has a guaranteed amount. Each year the insurer can add a bonus to it, and once added, that bonus is guaranteed too. Because the insurer decides the size of each bonus, it can smooth returns over good and bad years.
On death or at maturity, the insurer compares the asset share with the guaranteed amount:
- Asset share below the guarantee: The policy gets the guaranteed amount, and the insurer pays the difference from its own money
- Asset share above the guarantee: The policy gets a terminal bonus on top of the guaranteed amount. The bonuses come from the asset share, and for each CHF 9 of bonus paid to the policyholder, the insurer takes CHF 1. This 90/10 split and the guarantee charge are the insurer's margin on the product.
On surrender, the guarantee does not apply and the policyholder gets the asset share.
Money flows
In the first figure, the pool earns the expected 3% each year. The asset share ends above the guaranteed amount of CHF 9'459, so the policy also gets a terminal bonus.
The second figure compares the asset share with the guarantee in three outcomes:
- Poor: The asset share is below the guaranteed amount, so the insurer adds CHF 1'459 from its own money
- Expected and strong: The asset share is above the guaranteed amount, so the policy gets a terminal bonus. The insurer keeps 10% of the surplus paid out, which is CHF 181 in the expected outcome and CHF 400 in the strong one.
Premium CHF 10'000 | Commission CHF −250 | Into the pool CHF 9'750 | Pool return 5 years CHF 1'525 | Guarantee charge CHF −262 | Admin costs CHF −200 | Asset share CHF 10'813 | Insurer's 10% share CHF −181 | Paid at maturity CHF 10'632
- Premium10'000
- Commission−250
- Into thepool9'750
- Pool return5 years+1'525
- Guaranteecharge−262
- Admincosts−200
- Assetshare10'813
- Insurer's10% share−181
- Paid atmaturity10'632
Poor | pool falls | Asset share CHF 8'000 | Paid to the policyholder CHF 9'459 | Insurer keeps or pays in CHF −1'459 | Expected | 3% a year | Asset share CHF 10'813 | Paid to the policyholder CHF 10'632 | Insurer keeps or pays in CHF 181 | Strong | pool grows fast | Asset share CHF 13'000 | Paid to the policyholder CHF 12'600 | Insurer keeps or pays in CHF 400
Features of with-profits
- Guaranteed amount: CHF 9'000, plus each reversionary bonus once declared
- Bonus discretion: The insurer decides each year's bonus
- 90/10 split: For each CHF 9 of bonus paid, the insurer gets CHF 1
- Guarantee charge: The insurer receives the charge and pays any shortfall from its own money
Many real with-profits funds also hold an estate. This is surplus from past years that belongs to no single policy, and it can pay shortfalls before the insurer has to.
This example has no estate, so the insurer carries the guarantee alone (see Funds with an estate).
Contract terms
The policy uses the same premium, term, costs and fund returns as the unit-linked policy, so the two products compare directly.
| Feature | What the contract says | Who carries the risk |
|---|---|---|
| Premium | A single premium of CHF 10'000, paid into the pool that all with-profits policyholders share | – |
| Asset share | The policy's share of the pool, equal to the premium plus the pool's return, minus costs and the guarantee charge | Shared, smoothed by the insurer |
| Guaranteed amount | Sum assured of CHF 9'000, paid on death or at maturity | Insurer (investment risk on the guarantee) |
| Reversionary bonus | Declared by the insurer at each year-end, for example 1% of the guaranteed amount. Once declared, it is guaranteed. | Insurer decides (discretion) |
| Terminal bonus | Paid on death or at maturity if the asset share is high enough, with no guarantee | Policyholder |
| Profit sharing (90/10) | Policyholders get 90% of the distributed surplus. The insurer gets 10%, so it receives 1/9 of every bonus paid. | Shared |
| Surrender value | Based on the asset share, with no guarantee. The insurer can apply a market value reduction. | Policyholder |
| Costs | Commission (CHF 250) and administration (CHF 40 a year) are paid by the fund and taken from the asset share | Policyholders through the pool |
| Guarantee charge | 0.5% of the asset share each year, paid to the insurer. In return, the insurer pays any shortfall when the guarantee is above the asset share. | Insurer |
IFRS 17
Scope and recognition
In this example, the contract passes the VFA test. Condition (a) is met, and conditions (b) and (c) need judgment because of the guarantee.
Significant insurance risk
IFRS 17 applies only if the contract transfers significant insurance risk IFRS 17.B18–B23. On death, the policy pays the higher of the guaranteed amount and the asset share value. A surrender in the same year pays only the asset share value, so death can pay more IFRS 17.B20. The insurer must judge whether this extra amount is significant. If it is not, the contract is an investment contract with discretionary participation features IFRS 17.71.
Underlying items
- The with-profits pool holds the bonds, shares and property that the insurer invests for all with-profits policies. The contract specifies this fund.
- The underlying items are the whole pool, including the part that goes to the insurer
- Each policy's asset share is its part of the pool, and the payout on death, surrender or at maturity follows it
- If the fund held an estate, the estate would also be part of the pool. This example has none.
VFA conditions
| Condition | With-profits policy | Result |
|---|---|---|
| (a) A clearly identified pool | The with-profits fund. The insurer cannot change it with retrospective effect. | Met |
| (b) A substantial share of the returns | The 90/10 split applies only to distributed surplus, so it does not decide the test. The PV of payouts is 96.6% of the pool assets. IFRS 17 sets no minimum percentage IFRS 17.B107(a), but the link must be enforceable by contract or law IFRS 17.B105. | Judgment |
| (c) Payments vary with the pool | In most scenarios the payout follows the asset share, and the guarantee pays only in bad scenarios. The test looks at all scenarios together IFRS 17.B107(b) IFRS 17.B108. As a simple measure, a 10% fall in the pool moves the BEL by 71% of that fall. | Judgment, 71% |
The insurer does the test once, at inception of the contract, and does not repeat it IFRS 17.B102.
Annual cohorts
Policyholders who joined in different years share the pool, but IFRS 17.22 still requires annual cohorts. The EU version of IFRS lets companies skip this rule for such contracts (Regulations 2021/2036 and 2023/1803). A company that uses this option complies with IFRS as adopted by the EU, but not with IFRS as issued by the IASB.
| Step | Unit-linked | With-profits |
|---|---|---|
| VFA test IFRS 17.B101 | The account value follows a specific fund. The contract passes. | The pool is the underlying items. The 90/10 link must be enforceable IFRS 17.B105. Conditions (b) and (c) need judgment. |
| Cohorts | Annual cohorts | Annual cohorts under IFRS 17.22. EU-adopted IFRS has an optional exemption for some shared pools. IFRS 17.B70 still applies. |
Cash flow projection
The steps are the same as for unit-linked, except that the guarantee is an option. It has no cost on the expected path and a cost only in bad markets, so the insurer projects the fund over many market paths instead of one IFRS 17.B37–B39 IFRS 17.B48 IFRS 17.B77.
Step 1: Set the assumptions
The group, the deaths, the surrenders and the costs are the same as for unit-linked. With-profits also needs the fund volatility, the number of paths and the bonus rule. All deaths, surrenders and maturities happen at year-end, and only the fund return differs between paths. This example has no risk adjustment (RA).
| Line item | How it is calculated | Value |
|---|---|---|
| aNumber of policies sold | One group, issued on the same day. Same as unit-linked | 1'000 |
| bRisk-free rate | Discount rate and expected fund return on every path | 3.0% |
| cFund volatility | Spread of the yearly returns across paths, set to match market prices IFRS 17.B48 | 10% |
| dNumber of paths | Random market scenarios | 20'000 |
| eDeaths each year | Of policies in force at the start of the year. Same as unit-linked | 1.0% |
| fSurrenders each year (years 1–4) | Of policies in force at the start of the year. Same as unit-linked | 5.0% |
| gCommission and set-up cost | Per policy, paid at the start of the coverage period | 250 |
| hAdministration cost | Per policy in force at the start of the year, paid at year-end | 40 |
| iBonus rule | Declare 1% of the guaranteed amount only if the asset share is above it | 1% |
Simplifications
- The valuation uses 20'000 risk-neutral lognormal paths (fixed seed, antithetic pairs) and one flat discount curve
- There is one group of 1'000 policies with the same deaths and surrenders as unit-linked. The surrender rates are fixed, so there are no dynamic lapses. There is no RA and no estate. The insurer gets the guarantee charge and pays any shortfall.
- Bonuses follow a simple rule, and the model does not smooth them. It also does not allocate shared cash flows between groups IFRS 17.B68–B70 IFRS 17.B103.
- Volatility and rates are inputs here. In practice they must match observable market prices IFRS 17.B48.
- All cash flows occur at year-end, except the premium and commission at the start of the coverage period. There is no inflation and no tax.
Asset share growth
The asset share rises with the pool return and falls with the guarantee charge and the costs. The guaranteed amount grows separately with each bonus that the insurer declares.
On the expected path in the asset share table, the asset share stays above the guaranteed amount. The policy earns a terminal bonus, the payout on death or at maturity equals the value from the asset share, and the insurer pays no shortfall. If the pool falls far enough, the value from the asset share drops below the guaranteed amount and the insurer pays the difference. So the guarantee has a cost only on paths where the pool falls, and the single expected path cannot show that cost.
Insurer income and costs
The insurer keeps the guarantee charge and 1/9 of every bonus, and pays any shortfall below the guarantee. The fund pays the commission and the administration costs. Row d in Insurer margin shows the margin on the expected path, before the cost of the guarantee.
| Line item | How it is calculated | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| aTransfer to the insurer at maturity | l in Asset share year 5 | 181.30 |
| bGuarantee charges received | Sum of −c in Asset share over 5 years | 261.74 |
| cCommission, set-up and administration | Paid by the fund | – |
| dMargin for the insurer | a + b + c | 443.04 |
| eCompare: unit-linked margin | Unit-linked page, e | 575.43 |
Step 2: Project the policies in force
Each year, deaths and surrenders reduce the number of policies in force, and the policies that remain mature at the end of year 5. These counts are the same on every path.
| Line item | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| aIn force at start of yearYear 1: a in Assumptions. Later years: prior year e | 1'000.00 | 940.00 | 883.60 | 830.58 | 780.75 |
| bDeathsa × 1% | −10.00 | −9.40 | −8.84 | −8.31 | −7.81 |
| cSurrendersa × 5% (none in year 5) | −50.00 | −47.00 | −44.18 | −41.53 | – |
| dMaturitiesYear 5: a + b | – | – | – | – | −772.94 |
| eIn force at end of yeara + b + c + d | 940.00 | 883.60 | 830.58 | 780.75 | – |
Step 3: Project the pool, 20'000 times
Each path draws a random fund return for each year, with an expected return equal to the risk-free rate, and then applies the bonus rule and the guarantee. With a volatility of 10% and a risk-free rate of 3%, the guarantee pays at maturity on 30% of the paths. The guarantee line in the figure below is the sum assured of CHF 9'000. Declared bonuses raise the guaranteed amount above this line, so some paths that end above it also need a top-up.
At maturity the 5th percentile is CHF 7'254, the median is CHF 10'542, the one path at 3% is CHF 10'813, and the 95th percentile is CHF 15'302. The guarantee is CHF 9'000. The gray lines are illustrative sample paths.
Step 4: Read the cash flows
The model multiplies the deaths, surrenders and maturities on each path by the payout on that path, and then averages over all paths. The result is one set of expected cash flows for each year, which no single path has to produce exactly. Deaths and surrenders pay out each year, and the rest of the group pays out at maturity in year 5.
The guarantee charge and the transfer to the insurer are the insurer's share. They are not in the projected cash flows and instead go to the contractual service margin (CSM).
| Line item | Start | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| aPremiums1'000 × 10'000, paid at the start of the coverage period | 10'000'000 | – | – | – | – | – |
| bCommission and set-up1'000 × 250, paid at the start of the coverage period | −250'000 | – | – | – | – | – |
| cAdministration costs40 × a in Policies in force, the same on every path | – | −40'000 | −37'600 | −35'344 | −33'223 | −31'230 |
| dDeath: asset share payoutDeaths × the asset share payout, averaged over the paths | – | −98'494 | −94'260 | −90'269 | −86'451 | −82'807 |
| eDeath: guarantee top-upDeaths × max(0, guaranteed amount − asset share payout), averaged | – | −809 | −1'493 | −1'965 | −2'224 | −2'395 |
| fSurrender paymentsSurrenders × the asset share payout, averaged. No guarantee | – | −492'472 | −471'300 | −451'344 | −432'254 | – |
| gMaturity: asset share payoutMaturities × the asset share payout, averaged. Year 5 only | – | – | – | – | – | −8'197'941 |
| hMaturity: guarantee top-upMaturities × max(0, guaranteed amount − asset share payout), averaged | – | – | – | – | – | −237'090 |
| iNet cash flowa + b + … + h | 9'750'000 | −631'776 | −604'654 | −578'922 | −554'152 | −8'551'463 |
Changes that need a rerun
At each reporting date, the insurer updates the cash flows. A new run of all 20'000 paths is needed only if the value per policy changes. The rerun keeps the same random draws, so the change in the BEL comes only from the new input. In practice the market almost always moves, so the model runs at every reporting date. The table below shows which changes need a rerun.
In a pool shared across groups, a large change in another group can also need a rerun IFRS 17.B68–B71.
| Change | With a guarantee | No guarantee (unit-linked) | Effect goes to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deaths or surrenders this year differ from expected. Future rates stay the same | No. Multiply the value per policy by the actual number of policies | No. Same approach | Death benefit above the asset share: Profit or loss IFRS 17.B97(c). Asset share paid: Investment component, outside revenue and expenses IFRS 17.85. Future fees and guarantee cost lost: CSM |
| Future death rate changes. Same rate on every path | No, if the model stores the average payout for each exit year. Apply the new probabilities to those payouts. If it does not store them, yes | No. One new projection | CSM |
| Future surrender rate changes. Same rate on every path | No, on the same condition as the death rate | No. One new projection | CSM |
| Dynamic lapse rule changes. The rate depends on the fund on each path | Yes. Each path has its own lapses, so stored averages cannot be reused | Usually not modeled | CSM |
| Cost assumption changes | Yes if the fund pays the costs, as here, because the asset share changes on every path. No if the insurer pays them | No. One new projection | CSM |
| Bonus rule changes, or a declared bonus differs from the assumption | Yes. The asset share payout or the guaranteed amount changes on every path | Not applicable | CSM |
| Fund value moves | Yes. The paths start from the new value, and the guarantee does not scale. A 10% fall moves the guarantee cost from 212'549 to 402'726 | No. Payouts and charges move with the account value | CSM. If the CSM reaches zero, a loss IFRS 17.48 |
| Risk-free rate moves | Yes. It changes the path returns and the discounting | No paths needed. One new projection | CSM, unless the risk mitigation option applies |
| Volatility moves | Yes. The scenarios must match market prices IFRS 17.B48 | No effect | CSM, unless the risk mitigation option applies |
| Time passes to the next reporting date | Yes. Start from the current asset share and guaranteed amount, for the remaining years | No paths needed. One new projection | The new closing BEL. CSM is released for the service given |
| New policies are sold | Only for the new group | One projection for the new group | A new CSM for that group |
- IFRS 17.B37–B39 IFRS 17.B48: Use stochastic modeling when the cash flows respond non-linearly to asset returns, for example with a guarantee. Measure options and guarantees consistently with market prices.
- IFRS 17.B108: With a minimum return guarantee, the payments vary with the underlying items in some scenarios and not in others
Initial measurement
The underlying items are the with-profits pool. The insurer's share is its 1/9 of each bonus and the guarantee charge.
- Guarantee valuation: The guarantee is an option, so one projection cannot value it (see Cash flow projection).
- BEL: The BEL includes the guarantee top-up in bad scenarios and future bonuses, even though the insurer decides the bonuses IFRS 17.B65
| Step | Unit-linked | With-profits |
|---|---|---|
| Future bonuses | None | Part of the cash flows, even though the insurer decides them IFRS 17.B65 |
| Discount rate | Risk-free rate, which is also the assumed fund return | Same rule. A lower rate increases the guarantee cost (see Drivers of the guarantee cost). |
| BEL | PV of account values, death extra and costs | PV of payouts, including the guarantee top-up in bad scenarios |
| CSM at the start of the coverage period | Future charges minus fixed costs and RA | Insurer's share of bonuses and charges, minus the guarantee cost |
Variable fee
The variable fee is the insurer's share of the pool, minus the cash flows that do not move with the pool. The insurer's share has two parts:
- The guarantee charge: 0.5% of the asset share each year
- The transfer: 1/9 of every bonus paid, under the 90/10 split
Both parts rise and fall with the pool. The guarantee cost rises when the pool falls, so it reduces the variable fee. For the whole group at the start of the coverage period, averaged over 20'000 market scenarios:
- Pool assets for the group of 1'000 policies: CHF 9'750'000 (see Cash flow projection)
- Minus the PV of the payout from the asset share and of the costs: CHF 9'369'490
- Insurer's share before the guarantee: CHF 380'510
- Minus the guarantee cost: CHF 212'549
- CSM: CHF 167'961
IFRS 17.B104: The obligation is the fair value of the underlying items, minus a variable fee. IFRS 17.B65: Cash flows inside the boundary include those over which the entity has discretion, such as future bonuses.
IFRS 17.B68–B71: When policyholders of one group share in the same pool as other groups, the fulfilment cash flows of each group include the payments it causes to the others, including future policyholders.
Guarantee cost drivers
Higher volatility gives more bad paths, so the guarantee costs more. A lower rate makes the pool grow more slowly toward the guarantee, which also raises the cost. The payouts from the asset share change with volatility too, because the insurer takes 10% of the surplus paid out on the good paths. For this reason, the fall in row d in Guarantee cost from the 0% column is smaller than the increase in row c in Guarantee cost.
At 15% volatility or more, the group is onerous at the start of the coverage period IFRS 17.16(a) IFRS 17.47. The insurer must use a volatility that matches observable market prices IFRS 17.B48.
| Line item | Scenario 1 | Scenario 2 | Scenario 3 | Scenario 4 | Scenario 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| aFund volatilityInput. 0% is the single deterministic path | 0% | 10% | 15% | 20% | 10% |
| bRisk-free rateInput | 3% | 3% | 3% | 3% | 2% |
| cPV of the guarantee top-upe in Cash flows + h in Cash flows, discounted. A new run of the paths for each scenario | – | 212'549 | 464'519 | 739'168 | 308'799 |
| dNet inflow or outflow at initial recognitionAssets minus the BEL. Positive: This is the CSM. Negative: The CSM is 0 and this is a loss at the start of the coverage period IFRS 17.47 | 360'129 | 167'961 | −56'243 | −300'318 | 46'225 |
| eShare of paths where the guarantee paysPaths with a top-up in year 5 | 0% | 30% | 40% | 46% | 38% |
Subsequent measurement
With-profits contracts follow the same accounting steps as unit-linked.
Because of the guarantee, the BEL can fall much less than the pool in a market fall. The CSM absorbs the difference, and the group can become onerous (see A 10% market fall).
| Step | Unit-linked | With-profits |
|---|---|---|
| Market fall | Small CSM change from lost future charges | Large CSM change, because the guarantee cost rises IFRS 17.B113(b). The group can become onerous. |
| Coverage units | Account value plus death cover | One option is the higher of the guaranteed amount and the asset share. The insurer discloses this judgment IFRS 17.117(c)(v). |
| Hedging | No hedge in this example. If the insurer hedges its fee income with derivatives, it can use the risk mitigation option for that too IFRS 17.B115(a). | A hedge held outside the fund can use the risk mitigation option IFRS 17.B115–B116. A hedge inside the fund may be an underlying item IFRS 17.B106. |
A 10% market fall
The CSM rule is the same as for unit-linked. The change in the fund minus the change in the BEL goes to the CSM. Because of the guarantee, the BEL falls less than the fund, so the insurer's share takes more of the fall.
For unit-linked, the insurer loses only future charges. For with-profits, the guarantee cost also rises by CHF 190'177. The total change uses up the CSM, and the rest is an immediate loss IFRS 17.48(a) IFRS 17.48(b).
| Line item | How it is calculated | Operation | Unit-linked | With-profits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| aChange in the fund | −10% of the fund | −975'000 | −975'000 | |
| bChange in BEL | BEL before − BEL after | + | +911'938 | +692'524 |
| of which: guarantee cost | Change in the PV of the guarantee top-up | – | (−190'177) | |
| cChange in CSM | a + b | = | −63'062 | −282'476 |
| dCSM before the fall | CSM at initial recognition for one path | + | 426'767 | 167'961 |
| eCSM before the floor | c + d | = | 363'705 | −114'515 |
| Apply floor at CSM = 0 | ||||
| fCSM after the fall | e, but not below zero | 363'705 | – | |
| gLoss in profit or loss now (loss component) | The part of e that the CSM cannot absorb | – | −114'515 | |
In the figure below, each product's CSM before the fall is set to 100%. The part left of zero is the immediate with-profits loss.
Unit-linked | 15% of the CSM | CSM before CHF 426'767 | Change from the fall CHF −63'062 | CSM after CHF 363'705 | With-profits | 168% of the CSM | CSM before CHF 167'961 | Change from the fall CHF −282'476 | CSM after CHF 0 | Loss now CHF −114'515
Unit-linked
15%
of the CSM is used up
- CSM before
- 426'767
- Change from the fall
- −63'062
- CSM after
- 363'705
With-profits
168%
of the CSM is needed (CSM gone, rest is a loss)
- CSM before
- 167'961
- Change from the fall
- −282'476
- CSM after
- 0
- Loss now
- −114'515
Insurer actions
- Cut future bonuses. Declared bonuses cannot be cut, and the model already expects smaller bonuses in a bad market, so only a cut beyond expected practice changes the BEL.
- Hedge the guarantee and use the risk mitigation option IFRS 17.B115. A hedge held inside the fund may itself be an underlying item IFRS 17.B106.
- Disclose the effect of that choice IFRS 17.112 and the market sensitivity IFRS 17.128
Group-level test
- IFRS 17.48 tests the whole group at the reporting date. The amounts here are for the whole group of 1'000 policies.
- Because a 10% fall makes this group onerous, it already has a significant possibility of becoming onerous at the start of the coverage period. So it goes in the group of remaining contracts IFRS 17.16(c).
- If a loss arises, a later recovery reverses it first IFRS 17.50(b). Any loss component left is allocated over the remaining cover IFRS 17.50(a).
Funds with an estate
An estate is surplus in the with-profits fund that belongs to no single policy and builds up over many years from past policyholders. This example has no estate, so the insurer takes the guarantee charge and pays any shortfall. If the fund had an estate that took the charge and paid the shortfalls, the cost would fall on other policyholders, and the fulfilment cash flows would include the payments to them IFRS 17.B68. The CSM would then be about CHF 168'585, which is the PV of the transfers to the insurer. After the fall it would be about CHF 97'630, with no loss. These figures are a rough bound, because they ignore any insurer share of the estate and how the estate is paid out.
IFRS 17.B113(b): The change in the effect of financial guarantees adjusts the CSM. IFRS 17.48: The group becomes onerous if the unfavorable changes in the fulfilment cash flows IFRS 17.48(a) and the decrease in the entity's share IFRS 17.48(b) together exceed the CSM. The excess is a loss.
IFRS 17.50(b): Later favourable changes reduce the loss component first. IFRS 17.B115–B116: An entity with a previously documented risk-management strategy may recognize some of these changes in profit or loss instead.
Extra disclosures
The statements and notes follow the Presentation and disclosure, including the disclosures for all VFA contracts. With-profits adds two judgments to disclose IFRS 17.117. These are how the insurer sets future bonuses and how it allocates the shared pool's cash flows between groups IFRS 17.B70. Because of the guarantee, the market sensitivity is non-linear, and many guarantees at the same level are a concentration of risk IFRS 17.127 IFRS 17.128 (Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/2036).
Reference
FAQ
With-profits
The same way as for unit-linked. The rate is current and risk-free, with no illiquidity premium, because it must reflect the liquidity of the contracts IFRS 17.B79 and the policyholder can surrender at any time for the asset share. The scenarios are consistent with market prices, and each one projects the pool at a random return whose average is the risk-free rate IFRS 17.B48 IFRS 17.B77.
Yes. The payout in each scenario is the higher of the guaranteed amount and the asset share payout. The average top-up is the cost of the guarantee, and it is part of the BEL (see Projected cash flows of the group).
The policyholder still gets the guarantee. The BEL falls less than the fund, so the insurer's share falls more. The CSM absorbs it. If the CSM is too small, the excess is a loss now (see CSM before and after a 10% fall).
Only if the value of one policy changes in a way that depends on the path. A market move or a dynamic lapse rule needs a rerun. Different deaths this year need only the new policy count. A fixed death or surrender rate can reuse stored payouts by exit year (see Rerun of the paths, by type of change).
An endowment pays a fixed sum on death or maturity. Without a link to a pool of underlying items it fails the VFA test and uses the general measurement model (GMM). With profit participation, it may pass IFRS 17.B101.
Glossary
Show the 20 terms
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Asset share | A with-profits policy's share of the pool, equal to the premium plus returns, minus costs and charges. |
| BEL | Best estimate liability. This term is not in IFRS 17. The standard uses “estimates of the present value of the future cash flows” IFRS 17.101(a). |
| Coverage units | The quantity of service in each period. They set how fast the CSM is released. |
| CSM | Contractual service margin. The profit not yet earned. |
| Estate | Surplus in a with-profits fund not yet allocated to any policyholder. The example on this page has none. |
| GMM | General measurement model. The default IFRS 17 model. |
| Guarantee cost | The average top-up the insurer pays when the guarantee is above the asset share or account value. It equals the value of the guarantee, which is its intrinsic value plus its time value. |
| Hedge | Derivatives or other instruments whose value moves against the guarantee cost, so that gains offset losses. |
| Investment component | The amount paid to the policyholder in all cases. It is excluded from revenue and expenses. |
| Loss component | The part of the liability that tracks losses on an onerous group. |
| Market value reduction | A cut that the insurer can apply to a with-profits surrender payment after markets fall. It keeps the payment in line with the asset share. |
| Onerous | A group of contracts is onerous when it is expected to make a loss. The insurer recognizes the loss in profit or loss at once IFRS 17.47 IFRS 17.48. |
| PV | Present value. A future amount discounted to today. |
| RA | Risk adjustment for non-financial risk. |
| Reversionary bonus | A bonus added to the guaranteed amount each year. Once declared, it is guaranteed. |
| Risk mitigation option | The choice in IFRS 17.B115 to take hedged financial changes in the guarantee cost, or in the insurer's share of the items, to profit or loss instead of the CSM. |
| Risk-neutral | A projection where every asset is expected to earn the risk-free rate. |
| Terminal bonus | A bonus paid on death or at maturity if the asset share is high enough. It is not guaranteed. |
| Underlying items | The items that determine some of the amounts payable to a policyholder. They can be any items. On this page, they are the with-profits pool. |
| VFA | Variable fee approach. The IFRS 17 model for contracts with direct participation features. |