IFRS 17

Variable annuity

This page applies the variable fee approach to variable annuities. It covers the death and maturity guarantees, cash flow projection, guarantee cost and hedging.

Product

What is a variable annuity?

A variable annuity is a savings product that can later pay an income. The name comes from the United States, where these products started. "Annuity" refers to the income, and "variable" means that the value moves with investment funds.

Most variable annuities are deferred. They have two phases:

  • Savings phase: The premium buys units in funds that the policyholder chooses. The account value moves with the funds, as in unit-linked. The insurer guarantees a minimum on death and at the end of the phase.
  • Income phase: At the end of the savings phase, the policyholder can take the account value as a lump sum or convert it into an income paid every year until death.

This example covers only the savings phase, which ends with a lump sum at the end of year 5. The guarantees in this phase drive the VFA accounting. An income phase adds a life annuity, which is valued with the usual mortality assumptions. Some products also guarantee the income itself (GMWB or GMIB), but this example does not include them.

In the savings phase the insurer gives two guarantees:

  • Death (GMDB): The beneficiary gets at least the premium, CHF 10'000.
  • Maturity (GMAB): The policyholder gets at least CHF 9'000, 90% of the premium.

When the policy pays out, the insurer compares the account value with the guarantee. If the account value is higher, the policy pays the account value. If the account value is lower, the policy pays the guarantee and the insurer pays the difference from its own money. In return, the insurer takes a guarantee charge of 1.0% a year, on top of the 1.5% fund charge.

The policyholder keeps the gains, and the insurer carries the losses below the guarantees. Many insurers hedge this risk with derivatives.

Money flows

All of the premium buys units. On the 3% path in the first figure, the account stays above CHF 9'000, so the insurer pays no top-up.

The second figure compares the account value with each guarantee in three outcomes:

  • Large fall: The account falls to CHF 7'000. The insurer tops it up by CHF 2'000 at maturity, or by CHF 3'000 on death.
  • Small fall: The account falls to CHF 9'500. This is above the maturity floor of CHF 9'000 but below the death floor of CHF 10'000, so the insurer pays a top-up of CHF 500 only on death.
  • Steady growth: The account grows 3% a year and stays above both floors. The policy pays the account value, and the insurer pays nothing.

In every outcome the insurer earns the guarantee charge of 1.0% a year. Unlike with-profits, a variable annuity has no bonus for the insurer to share. The insurer's income comes only from the charges, which move with the account value.

One policy from premium to payout on the 3% path

Premium CHF 10'000 | Fund return 5 years CHF 1'513 | Fund charge CHF −779 | Guarantee charge CHF −519 | Account value CHF 10'214 | GMAB top-up CHF 0 | Paid at maturity CHF 10'214

  1. Premium10'000
  2. Fund return5 years+1'513
  3. Fundcharge−779
  4. Guaranteecharge−519
  5. Accountvalue10'214
  6. GMABtop-up0
  7. Paid atmaturity10'214
What the policy pays in three outcomesAccount value at maturityAccount value on deathInsurer top-up

Large fall | to 7'000 | Account value CHF 7'000 | Paid at maturity (GMAB) CHF 9'000, insurer top-up CHF 2'000 | Paid on death (GMDB) CHF 10'000, insurer top-up CHF 3'000 | Small fall | to 9'500 | Account value CHF 9'500 | Paid at maturity (GMAB) CHF 9'500, insurer top-up CHF 0 | Paid on death (GMDB) CHF 10'000, insurer top-up CHF 500 | Steady growth | 3% a year | Account value CHF 10'214 | Paid at maturity (GMAB) CHF 10'214, insurer top-up CHF 0 | Paid on death (GMDB) CHF 10'214, insurer top-up CHF 0

+2'0007'000
+3'0007'000
9'500
+5009'500
10'214
10'214
MaturityDeathLarge fallto 7'000MaturityDeathSmall fallto 9'500MaturityDeathSteady growth3% a year

Contract terms

Contract terms for one variable annuity
FeatureWhat the contract saysWho carries the risk
PremiumA single premium of CHF 10'000. All of it buys units in the funds that the policyholder chooses, with no entry charge.–
Account valueUnits held × unit price, which moves with the fundsPolicyholder, above the guarantees
Charges1.5% fund charge and 1.0% guarantee charge, taken from the account each year after the return–
Death benefit (GMDB)The higher of the account value and CHF 10'000 (the premium paid)Insurer, when the account is below the premium
Maturity benefit (GMAB)At the end of year 5, the higher of the account value and CHF 9'000 (90% of the premium)Insurer, when the account is below CHF 9'000
CostsCommission of CHF 250 at the start of the coverage period and administration of CHF 40 a year, both paid by the insurerInsurer

Real savings phases often run for 10 years or longer. This example keeps the same five-year term and fund as the other pages, so that the numbers can be compared.

IFRS 17

Scope and recognition

In this example, the contract passes the VFA test. Condition (a) is met, and conditions (b) and (c) need judgment because of the charges and the guarantees.

Significant insurance risk

IFRS 17 applies only if the contract transfers significant insurance risk IFRS 17.B18–B23. On death the policy pays at least the premium, which can be more than the account value, so the contract transfers significant insurance risk.

Underlying items

  • The contract specifies the investment funds that the policyholder chooses.
  • The underlying items are the whole funds, including both the policyholders' part and the insurer's part. The insurer's charges are paid out of the funds.
  • Each policy's account value is the value of its units in the funds. The payout on death, surrender or maturity follows the account value, with a top-up when the account is below the guarantee.

VFA conditions

IFRS 17.B101 applied to the variable annuity
ConditionVariable annuityResult
(a) A clearly identified poolThe funds that the policyholder chooses, as specified in the contractMet
(b) A substantial share of the returnsThe policyholder gets the fund return minus 2.5% a year in charges. At a 3% return, the charges take 85.8% of the PV of the fund returns, and the policyholder keeps more at higher returns. The PV of the account values and top-ups paid to policyholders is 92.2% of the fund. IFRS 17 sets no percentage IFRS 17.B107(a).Judgment
(c) Payments vary with the poolIn most scenarios the payout is the account value. The guarantees pay only when the funds fall, and here the GMAB pays on 32% of the paths. Judge this over all scenarios, weighted by probability IFRS 17.B107(b). As a simple proxy, a 10% fall moves the BEL by 65% of the change in the fund (see A 10% fall in the fund).Judgment (65%)

If the guarantees are already well above the account value at inception, most of the payout no longer follows the funds. The contract may then fail condition (c) and use the general measurement model (GMM). The test weighs all scenarios IFRS 17.B108.

The insurer does the test for each contract once, at inception of the contract, and does not repeat it IFRS 17.B102. The percentages above are simple measures that support the judgment, but they do not replace the assessment in IFRS 17.B107.

StepUnit-linkedVariable annuity
VFA test IFRS 17.B101The account value follows a specific fund. The contract passes.The funds are the same. Conditions (b) and (c) need judgment IFRS 17.B107.

Cash flow projection

The steps are the same as for unit-linked. The guarantees pay only when the funds fall, so the insurer projects the account over many market paths instead of one IFRS 17.B37–B39 IFRS 17.B48 IFRS 17.B77.

Step 1: Set the assumptions

The group, the deaths, the surrenders and the costs are the same as for unit-linked and with-profits. All deaths, surrenders and maturities happen at year-end. Only the fund return differs between paths. This example has no risk adjustment (RA).

Best-estimate assumptions at initial recognition
Line itemHow it is calculatedValue
aNumber of policies soldOne group, issued on the same day. Same as unit-linked1'000
bRisk-free rateDiscount rate and expected fund return on every path3.0%
cFund volatilitySpread of the yearly returns across paths, set to match market prices IFRS 17.B4810%
dNumber of pathsRandom market scenarios20'000
eDeaths each yearOf policies in force at the start of the year. Same as unit-linked1.0%
fSurrenders each year (years 1–4)Of policies in force at the start of the year. Same as unit-linked5.0%
gCommission and set-up costPer policy, paid at the start of the coverage period250
hAdministration costPer policy in force at the start of the year, paid at year-end40

Simplifications

  • The model uses the same 20'000 risk-neutral lognormal paths as the with-profits page and one flat discount curve
  • The model has one group of 1'000 policies with the same deaths (1% a year) and surrenders (5% a year, none in year 5). Surrenders get no guarantee. There is no RA, and the term is five years.
  • The hedge matches the change in the guarantee cost exactly, and its cost is left out. Real hedges do not match exactly, so they leave basis risk.
  • The BEL includes the commission paid at the start of the coverage period, as an acquisition cash flow
  • All cash flows are at year-end, except at the start of the coverage period. There is no inflation and no tax.

Account value growth

The account value is the value of the units. It rises with the fund return and falls with the fund charge and the guarantee charge. With a 3% return, the account grows by about 0.4% a year after 2.5% in charges. The table shows the death, surrender and maturity amounts for each year, but each policy gets only one of them.

Account value of one variable annuity that stays to maturity
Line itemYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
Account value: the policyholder's money in the fund
aOpening account valueYear 1: 10'000 premium, all invested. Later years: prior year e10'000.0010'042.5010'085.1810'128.0410'171.09
bFund returna × 3%300.00301.27302.56303.84305.13
cFund charge−(a + b) × 1.5%−154.50−155.16−155.82−156.48−157.14
dGuarantee charge−(a + b) × 1.0%−103.00−103.44−103.88−104.32−104.76
eClosing account valuea + b + c + d10'042.5010'085.1810'128.0410'171.0910'214.31
Amount paid at year-end when death or surrender happens, or at maturity
fPaid if the policyholder dies this yearThe higher of e and 10'000 (GMDB)10'042.5010'085.1810'128.0410'171.0910'214.31
gof which: top-up paid by the insurer10'000 − e, if positive–––––
hPaid if the policyholder surrenders this yeare. No guarantee10'042.5010'085.1810'128.0410'171.09
iPaid at maturityThe higher of e and 9'000 (GMAB)10'214.31

Insurer income and costs

The insurer keeps the fund charge and the guarantee charge, and pays the commission, the administration costs and any top-up below the guarantees. Both charges are a percentage of the account, so the insurer's income moves with the market, as in unit-linked. On the 3% path the guarantees cost nothing. They cost money only on paths where the fund falls, so the insurer projects many paths to measure that cost.

Insurer's margin on one variable annuity that stays to maturity
Line itemHow it is calculatedAmount
aFund charges keptSum of −c in Account value over 5 years779.09
bGuarantee charges keptSum of −d in Account value over 5 years519.40
cCommission and set-up costPaid at the start−250
dAdministration costs40 × 5 years−200
eGMAB top-up at maturityNone on this path: i in Account value equals e in Account value–
fMargin for the insurera + b + c + d + e848.49

Step 2: Project the policies in force

The numbers of deaths and surrenders are the same on every path.

Step 3: Project the account, 20'000 times

The scenarios are the same 20'000 paths as on the with-profits page. On each path the account grows with the fund and pays 2.5% a year in charges. The GMAB pays at maturity on 32% of the paths.

Step 4: Read the cash flows

On each path, multiply the deaths, surrenders and maturities by the payout on that path, then average over all paths. Surrenders get the account value and no guarantee.

The charges stay in the fund, so the projected cash flows exclude them. They are the insurer's share and go to the contractual service margin (CSM).

Projected cash flows of the group, before discounting
Line itemStartYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
aPremiums1'000 × 10'000, paid at the start of the coverage period10'000'000–––––
bCommission and set-up1'000 × 250, paid at the start of the coverage period by the insurer−250'000–––––
cAdministration costs40 × a in Policies in force, the same on every path–−40'000−37'600−35'344−33'223−31'230
dDeath: account valueDeaths × the account value, averaged over the paths–−100'429−94'788−89'502−84'489−79'755
eDeath: GMDB top-upDeaths × max(0, 10'000 − account value), averaged–−3'818−4'899−5'620−5'981−6'230
fSurrender paymentsSurrenders × the account value, averaged. No guarantee–−502'144−473'939−447'511−422'446–
gMaturity: account valueMaturities × the account value, averaged. Year 5 only–––––−7'895'777
hMaturity: GMAB top-upMaturities × max(0, 9'000 − account value), averaged–––––−295'088
iNet cash flowa + b + … + h9'750'000−646'392−611'226−577'977−546'139−8'308'081

Initial measurement

The underlying items are the funds. The insurer's share is the charges.

The guarantees are options, so one projection cannot value them (see Cash flow projection and Guarantee valuation choices).

Comparison of unit-linked and variable annuity
StepUnit-linkedVariable annuity
BELPV of account values, death extra and costsPV of account values, costs and the guarantee top-ups
CSM at the start of the coverage periodFuture charges minus fixed costs and RAFuture charges minus fixed costs, RA and the guarantee cost

Variable fee

The variable fee is the insurer's share of the funds, minus the cash flows that do not move with the funds. The insurer's share has two parts:

  • The fund charge: 1.5% of the account value each year
  • The guarantee charge: 1% of the account value each year

Both charges move with the funds. The costs and the guarantee top-ups do not, so they reduce the variable fee. For the group of 1'000 policies at the start of the coverage period, as averages over 20'000 paths (see Cash flow projection):

  • Insurer's share of the funds: CHF 1'057'286 of future charges
  • Minus the fixed costs: CHF 413'079
  • Minus the guarantee cost: CHF 278'702
  • CSM: CHF 365'505

Guarantee valuation choices

The scenario projection already includes the guarantees. On each path, the payout is the higher of the account value and the guarantee, so the projected cash flows contain the top-ups (rows e and h). The BEL from these cash flows is the full BEL.

A simpler method splits the BEL into two parts and gives the same result. First value the contract as if it had no guarantee, then add the value of the guarantee as an option.

BEL=Base BEL+Option value
  • Base BEL: Project the cash flows and ignore the guarantee, even where the benefit falls below the guarantee
  • Option value: The extra expected cost of the guarantee, including its time value. In this example it is the PV of the GMDB and GMAB top-ups (d in Option value).

Subsequent measurement

Variable annuity contracts follow the same accounting steps as unit-linked.

  • Market fall: The insurer loses charges and pays more for the guarantees. The CSM can fall to zero (see A 10% market fall).
  • Hedging: The hedge gain goes to profit or loss. Without the risk mitigation option, the guarantee loss goes to the CSM (see Hedge gain and guarantee cost).
StepUnit-linkedVariable annuity
Market fallSmall CSM change from the lost future chargesThe CSM takes the lost charges and the higher guarantee cost IFRS 17.B113(b). The group can become onerous.
HedgingNo hedge in this example. If the insurer hedges its fee income with derivatives, it can use the risk mitigation option for that too IFRS 17.B115(a).A hedge can use the risk mitigation option, which sends hedged changes to profit or loss IFRS 17.B115–B116.
Coverage unitsAccount value plus death coverOne option is the higher of the account value and the guaranteed amount that applies. This is a judgment to disclose IFRS 17.117(c)(v).

A 10% market fall

As for unit-linked, the CSM changes by the fund change minus the BEL change. The guarantees make the BEL fall less than the fund, so the CSM takes more of the loss.

For unit-linked, the insurer loses only future charges. For the variable annuity, the insurer loses the same kind of charges (CHF 105'729) and also pays CHF 247'962 more for the guarantees. The CSM absorbs both and falls to CHF 11'814, 3% of its value before the fall. The group is not onerous, but a slightly larger fall makes it onerous IFRS 17.48.

A 10% fall in the fund on the day after the start of the coverage period
Line itemHow it is calculatedUnit-linkedVariable annuity
aCSM before the fallCSM at initial recognition, before the RA. One path for unit-linked and 20'000 paths for the VA426'767365'505
bChange in the fund (underlying items)−10% of the fund−975'000−1'000'000
cChange in the BELBEL after the fall − BEL before−911'938−646'309
dof which: guarantee top-upsChange in the PV of the GMDB and GMAB top-ups–247'962
eChange before the CSM limitb − c. The CSM takes this only down to zero−63'062−353'691
fCSM after the falla + e, but not below zero363'70511'814
gLoss in profit or loss now (loss component)The part of e that the CSM cannot absorb––

Hedging and the risk mitigation option

Suppose the insurer holds derivatives whose value moves exactly with the guarantee cost. The fall then gives a hedge gain of CHF 247'962, which always goes to profit or loss. The risk mitigation option decides where the change in the guarantee cost goes.

Hedge gain and guarantee cost, with and without the risk mitigation option
Line itemHow it is calculatedNo hedgeHedge, no optionHedge with the option
aGain on the hedgeDerivatives at fair value through profit or loss. Assumed to match d in 10% fall exactly–247'962247'962
bHigher guarantee costd in 10% fall−247'962−247'962−247'962
cof which: sent to the CSM, down to zeroWithout the option, all of b−247'962−247'962–
dof which: insurance finance expenseWith the option, all of b IFRS 17.B117A––−247'962
eLost charges, sent to the CSMe in 10% fall + d in 10% fall−105'729−105'729−105'729
fChange before the CSM limitc + e−353'691−353'691−105'729
gCSM after the falla in 10% fall + f, but not below zero11'81411'814259'776
hLoss componentThe part of f that the CSM cannot absorb–––
iProfit or loss nowa + d + h–247'962–
  • Without the option: A profit of CHF 247'962 now from the hedge gain, while the CSM falls to CHF 11'814. The hedge offsets the risk, but the accounting creates a mismatch between profit or loss and the CSM.
  • With the option: Profit or loss of 0 now, and a CSM of CHF 259'776. Only the lost charges reduce the CSM.
  • Over the life of the group the total profit is the same. The option changes only the timing.

Extra disclosures

The statements and notes follow the Presentation and disclosure, including the disclosures for all VFA contracts. A variable annuity adds the points that come from its guarantees:

  • Judgments on the scenarios and policyholder behavior used to value the guarantees IFRS 17.117. Volatility comes from market prices IFRS 17.B48.
  • Market sensitivity is non-linear because of the guarantees IFRS 17.128
  • Many guarantees at the same level are a concentration of risk IFRS 17.127
  • The effect on the CSM in the period, if the insurer hedges the guarantees and uses the risk mitigation option IFRS 17.112

Reference

FAQ

Variable annuity

Glossary

Show the 20 terms
TermMeaning
BELBest estimate liability. This term is not in IFRS 17. The standard uses “estimates of the present value of the future cash flows” IFRS 17.101(a).
Black-ScholesA formula for the market-consistent value of a simple option. It uses the fund value, the guaranteed amount, the term, the risk-free rate and the volatility.
Coverage unitsThe quantity of service in each period. They set how fast the CSM is released.
CSMContractual service margin. The profit not yet earned.
GMABGuaranteed minimum accumulation benefit. A minimum amount paid at maturity, whatever the funds do.
GMDBGuaranteed minimum death benefit. A minimum amount paid on death, whatever the funds do.
GMIBGuaranteed minimum income benefit. A minimum yearly income after the savings phase, whatever the funds do.
GMMGeneral measurement model. The default IFRS 17 model.
GMWBGuaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit. The right to withdraw a set amount each year until a guaranteed total is paid, whatever the funds do.
Guarantee costThe average top-up the insurer pays when the guarantee is above the asset share or account value. It is the value of the guarantee, which is the intrinsic value plus the time value.
HedgeDerivatives or other instruments whose value moves against the guarantee cost, so that gains offset losses.
Investment componentThe amount paid to the policyholder in all cases. It is excluded from revenue and expenses.
Loss componentThe part of the liability that tracks losses on an onerous group.
OnerousA group of contracts is onerous when it is expected to make a loss. The insurer recognizes the loss in profit or loss at once IFRS 17.47 IFRS 17.48.
PVPresent value. A future amount discounted to today.
RARisk adjustment for non-financial risk.
Risk mitigation optionThe choice in IFRS 17.B115 to take hedged financial changes in the guarantee cost, or in the insurer's share of the items, to profit or loss instead of the CSM.
Risk-neutralA projection where every asset is expected to earn the risk-free rate.
Underlying itemsThe items that determine some of the amounts payable to a policyholder. They can be any items. In this example, they are the funds.
VFAVariable fee approach. The IFRS 17 model for contracts with direct participation features.

Sources

Standards and IASB material