IFRS 17

Variable fee approach

This guide explains the variable fee approach under IFRS 17. It covers participating products, initial and subsequent measurement, reporting and a full five-year example.

Basics

What is the variable fee approach?

The variable fee approach (VFA) is the IFRS 17 measurement model for insurance contracts with direct participation features (the policyholder gets most of the investment return). The policyholder's payout depends on the value of a pool of assets (so-called underlying items). In return, the insurer charges a fee.

Underlying items and the variable fee

The policyholder's savings are invested in a fund. The insurer buys fund units with the premium after deducting the entry charge. The account value is the number of fund units multiplied by the price of each unit. The insurer's variable fee is what it expects to keep from charges after paying for death cover and administration IFRS 17.B104.

Money flows in the unit-linked example
Policyholder
Net premium
Account value
Investment fund
Fund charges
Insurer

Example used throughout the guide

The insurer issues unit-linked policies with these terms and measures them together as one contract group.

ItemValueExplanation
Policies1'000One contract group, issued on the same day
Term5 yearsThe policy ends at maturity, death, or surrender
Premium per policyCHF 10'000Paid once at the start of cover
Entry charge2.5%Deducted from the premium before investment
Annual management charge1.5%Deducted from the account value after each year's fund return
Extra death benefitCHF 1'000Paid by the insurer in addition to the account value
Surrender or maturity benefitAccount valueNo surrender penalty or guaranteed fund return

Building blocks

IFRS 17 values a group of contracts as the sum of three building blocks:

  • BEL (best estimate liability): The present value of expected future payments minus receipts
  • RA (risk adjustment for non-financial risk): The compensation the insurer requires for uncertainty in those cash flows
  • CSM (contractual service margin): The profit not yet earned

The insurer adds BEL and RA to get fulfilment cash flows (FCF). As it provides service, the insurer releases the CSM to profit or loss. It measures that service in coverage units.

What makes VFA different?

The general measurement model (GMM) and the VFA both value a group of contracts with the BEL, the RA and the CSM. They differ when it comes to financial market changes.

  • GMM: The insurer recognizes the effect of financial market changes in profit or loss or other comprehensive income (OCI), instead of adjusting the CSM IFRS 17.B97(a)
  • VFA: A market rise or fall changes the value of the pool of assets and the fee the insurer expects to earn. The insurer adjusts the CSM for this change in its future fee because it relates to future service IFRS 17.B112. If a fall in the expected fee exceeds the remaining CSM, the insurer recognizes the excess as a loss IFRS 17.45(b)

The insurer must apply VFA when a contract meets all three direct participation conditions IFRS 17.B101 IFRS 17.45. The premium allocation approach (PAA) is a simplified method for eligible contract groups IFRS 17.53. The Scope and recognition chapter covers eligibility in detail.

How to read the example

  • Perspective: The insurer issues the policies and accounts for its obligations to the policyholders
  • Scale: Product figures describe one policy, while accounting tables measure the whole contract group
  • Cash flow signs: Inflows are positive and outflows are negative
  • Balance signs: A positive BEL is a liability, and a positive CSM is unearned profit
  • Models: The example uses VFA, with GMM comparisons on the same cash flows
  • References: A bracketed reference such as IFRS 17.B104 links to an IFRS 17 paragraph

All amounts are in CHF. The example uses assumed charges, costs, and policyholder behavior. The cash flow projection sets out the remaining assumptions. The with-profits and variable annuity pages use separate product cases.

Simplifications

  • The example uses one fund, one flat discount curve and one deterministic projection
  • All cash flows occur at year-end, except at the start of the coverage period. There is no inflation and no tax.
  • The RA is a fixed percentage of the PV of non-unit outflows, so it leaves out lapse risk. Real methods use a confidence level or cost of capital.
  • All insurance finance income and expenses go to profit or loss. The example does not use the option to present part of them in other comprehensive income IFRS 17.88(b).

Products with participating features

A participating contract pays the policyholder a share of an investment return or a share of the insurer's profit. This share comes in addition to any guaranteed benefit. The sharing mechanism in the contract sets the measurement model.

Types of participation

  • Direct participation: The contract names a pool of assets and pays the policyholder most of its return. Examples: Unit-linked and many with-profits contracts.
  • Indirect participation: The insurer sets a crediting rate or a dividend after the period, with no specific pool. Example: Universal life.
  • Discretionary participation: The insurer decides the amount or timing of extra benefits, within the contract terms. Appendix A of IFRS 17 defines these features.

Direct, indirect and discretionary participation can overlap. A with-profits contract can be both direct and discretionary.

Insurance products

Each of these products has participating features, but not all of them apply the VFA (see Product comparison).

ProductHow the policyholder participatesTypical guaranteeUsual model
Unit-linkedThe account value is the value of assets in a specific fund (it moves with the fund every day)None, or a fixed extra on deathVFA
With-profits (conventional participating)Regular and final bonuses come from a with-profits fund. The contract or local rules fix the split of surplus between policyholders and shareholders, for example 90/10.Sum assured plus bonuses already declaredUsually VFA
Variable annuityThe account value follows funds that the policyholder choosesMinimum death, maturity, income or withdrawal benefitsUsually VFA
Universal lifeThe insurer credits interest at a rate (set each period newly)A minimum crediting rateUsually GMM
Investment contract with discretionary participationThe insurer decides on the bonuses (no significant insurance risk)Often a guaranteed rateVFA or GMM

Unit-linked, with-profits and variable annuity contracts each have a page that applies this guide to the product. For a step-by-step walkthrough of the VFA, continue with the IFRS 17 chapters below.

IFRS 17

Initial recognition and measurement

Scope and recognition

After identifying the participation features, the insurer tests whether the contract qualifies for VFA and decides when to recognize it.

Conditions

A contract has direct participation features only if it meets all three conditions in IFRS 17.B101:

  • (a) The contract says that the policyholder shares in a clearly identified pool of underlying items
  • (b) The insurer expects to pay the policyholder a substantial share of the fair value returns on the pool
  • (c) The insurer expects a substantial part of any change in the payments to vary with the fair value of the pool

Test application

  • Test at inception only and test again only if the contract is modified under IFRS 17.72 IFRS 17.B102
  • Judge “substantial” over the whole contract, with a probability-weighted average of present values IFRS 17.B107
  • A minimum guarantee does not by itself fail the test, but a large guarantee can fail condition (c) IFRS 17.B108
  • The pool can consist of any investments, for example a reference portfolio or the insurer's net assets. The insurer does not have to hold them IFRS 17.B106
  • The pool is not clearly identified if the insurer can change the items with retrospective effect IFRS 17.B106
  • Reinsurance contracts, issued or held, never use the VFA IFRS 17.B109

For the usual result by product, see Product comparison.

Recognition and contract groups

TopicDecision for this productIFRS 17 reference
When to recogniseAt the earliest of three dates: The start of the coverage period, the date the first premium is due, and the date the group becomes onerous. In this example cover starts and the single premium is due on the same day, and the group is not onerous.IFRS 17.25
Group of contractsThe contracts form one portfolio and one annual cohort. The group is profitable at the start of the coverage period (CSM > 0) and has no significant possibility of becoming onerous.IFRS 17.14–24
Contract boundaryThe policyholder pays one premium at the start of the coverage period for the whole 5-year term. The insurer cannot change the charges or end the contract before maturity. So all cash flows to maturity are inside the boundary.IFRS 17.34
Investment componentThe account value is paid in every case: On death, surrender or maturity. That amount is an investment component. It is not distinct: If the policyholder surrenders, the death cover ends too IFRS 17.B32(b). So the insurer does not separate it. It stays in the BEL with the other cash flows. It changes only the presentation: It is excluded from insurance revenue and insurance service expenses.IFRS 17.11(b) IFRS 17.85 IFRS 17.B31–B32
Other componentsThere is no embedded derivative to separate: Surrender pays the account value, with no guarantee. Fund management is not a distinct service.IFRS 17.11(a) IFRS 17.12 IFRS 17.B33
Underlying itemsThe underlying items are the fund. The insurer measures the fund assets under IFRS 9, here at fair value through profit or loss.IFRS 17.B106 (identification), IFRS 9 (measurement)

Product-specific scope rules

  • Annual cohorts: A pool shared across generations still needs annual cohorts IFRS 17.22. EU-adopted IFRS has an optional exemption for some of these contracts (see with-profits).
  • Investment contracts with discretionary participation: These contracts have no significant insurance risk. They are in IFRS 17 only if the insurer also issues insurance contracts IFRS 17.3(c). They cannot use the VFA, because IFRS 17.B101 applies only to insurance contracts. IFRS 17.71 changes three GMM rules: When to recognise the contract, which future cash flows belong to it, and how to release the CSM (over the investment service).

Fulfilment cash flows

After defining the contract group and its cash flows, the insurer estimates the present value of future payments and receipts (BEL) and adds the risk adjustment for non-financial risk (RA). Together they form fulfilment cash flows (FCF).

Discount rate

The discount rate is a current rate. It reflects the time value of money and the characteristics of the cash flows IFRS 17.36.

The bottom-up method starts from a liquid risk-free curve and adds an illiquidity premium IFRS 17.B80. The top-down method starts from the yield on a reference portfolio and removes credit risk IFRS 17.B81 (EIOPA 2024, Canadian Institute of Actuaries 2025).

This example uses the CHF risk-free curve with no illiquidity premium. The policyholder can surrender at any time for the full account value, so the liability is liquid.

Discount rates used at each valuation date
Line itemStartYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4
aRisk-free rate (CHF)Observed in the market at the date3%3%3%2%2%
bIlliquidity premiumZero: the policyholder can surrender at any time for the full account0%0%0%0%0%
cDiscount rate used for the BEL and RAa + b3%3%3%2%2%
dRate used to adjust the CSM (VFA)Current rate. There is no locked-in rate under the VFA3%3%3%2%2%
eRate used to adjust the CSM (GMM)Locked-in rate from initial recognition (IFRS 17.B72(b)–(c))3%3%3%3%3%

Assumed fund return

Cash flows that vary with the fund must be valued consistently with market prices IFRS 17.33(b) IFRS 17.36(b). The usual method is risk-neutral: Project the fund at the risk-free rate and discount at the same rate. The rate then cancels out of the account-value payments. A higher rate increases the projected account values and the discounting by the same amount. So the PV of the account values depends only on today's account value and the charges.

The discount rate matters mainly for the fixed amounts: The CHF 1'000 death extra and the administration costs. They do not grow with the rate, so a higher rate only discounts them more. Their PV falls, so the BEL and the RA fall and the CSM rises.

  • Assumed return: 3%, then 2% after the year-3 rate cut
  • Actual return: A market outcome, which the insurer does not use as a discount rate

Present value of each cash flow

Present value at initial recognition of each expected cash flow
Line itemYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Total PV
aYears from initial recognition to paymentAll payments at year-end12345
bDiscount factor1 ÷ 1.03 ^ a0.9708740.9425960.9151420.8884870.862609
cPV death: account value partc in Cash flows × b−96'038−88'921−82'332−76'231−70'582−414'104
dPV death: extra CHF 1'000 partd in Cash flows × b−9'709−8'860−8'086−7'380−6'734−40'769
ePV surrender paymentse in Cash flows × b−480'187−444'606−411'660−381'157–−1'717'610
fPV maturity paymentsf in Cash flows × b––––−6'987'670−6'987'670
gPV administration costsg in Cash flows × b−38'835−35'442−32'345−29'518−26'939−163'079
hPV of future outflowsc + d + e + f + g−624'769−577'829−534'423−494'286−7'091'925−9'323'232

Guarantees and discretionary bonuses

  • Guarantees and options: A guarantee pays only when the fund falls below it, so the expected path shows no cost. The insurer projects the fund over many market scenarios and includes the average guarantee payment in the BEL. A market fall raises this payment. This can use up the CSM and make the group onerous IFRS 17.48 (see with-profits and variable annuity).
  • Bonuses: The insurer decides future bonuses. The BEL includes the bonuses it expects to declare IFRS 17.B65 (see with-profits).

Initial measurement

Once the insurer has measured fulfilment cash flows, it calculates the initial CSM as the premium minus commission minus those fulfilment cash flows.

Opening measurement

ComponentWhat it isFor this product
BEL (best estimate liability)The PV of all future cash flows to fulfil the contracts. It uses probability weights, current assumptions and current rates.PV of account values paid + PV of death extra + PV of costs.
RA (risk adjustment)The compensation the insurer needs for bearing non-financial risk.5% of the PV of death-extra and cost outflows. This is a simple method for teaching.
CSM (contractual service margin)The profit that the insurer has not yet earned. It is released as the insurer provides service.The variable fee: The insurer's share of the fund, minus fixed costs and the RA.

The BEL and the RA are the fulfilment cash flows. The CSM is the premium minus commission minus the fulfilment cash flows. A positive CSM means the group is not onerous. The CSM goes to profit or loss over the 5 years, as the insurer provides the service (see Coverage units and CSM release). The figure below gives amounts in CHF, with k for thousand and m for million.

From premiums to CSM at initial recognition

Premiums CHF 10'000'000 | Commission CHF −250'000 | BEL CHF −9'323'232 | RA CHF −10'192 | CSM CHF 416'576

  1. Premiums10.00m
  2. Commission−250k
  3. BEL−9.32m
  4. RA−10k
  5. CSM417k
Initial measurement: BEL, RA and CSM
Line itemHow it is calculatedAmount
aPremiums received at initial recognitiona in Cash flows10'000'000
bCommission and set-up paid at initial recognitionb in Cash flows−250'000
cCash received net at initial recognitiona + b9'750'000
dBest estimate liability (BEL)PV of future outflows: −h in Present values total9'323'232
eRisk adjustment (RA)5% × (PV death extra + PV administration) = 5% × −(d in Present values + g in Present values) totals10'192
fFulfilment cash flows (FCF)d + e9'333'424
gContractual service margin (CSM)c − f. Positive, so the group is not onerous416'576
hInsurance contract liabilityf + g. Equals c9'750'000

CSM as a variable fee

The insurer owes the policyholder the fund, minus a variable fee IFRS 17.B104. The fee is the insurer's share of the fund, minus the cash flows that do not vary with the fund. At the start of the coverage period, that fee is the CSM.

Each policy pays a premium of CHF 10'000. The insurer keeps an entry charge of CHF 250 and invests CHF 9'750 in units. The entry charge pays the commission and set-up costs.

The fund is CHF 9'750'000 of units today. The AMC takes 1.5% of the fund each year until payout. The insurer's share of the fund is the PV of those charges.

Deduct the death extra, the costs and the RA from the insurer's share. The result is the variable fee, and it equals the CSM.

The columns in the figure below are to scale. The right column enlarges the insurer's share of CHF 630'616.

The fund at initial recognition, split by who gets it

Fund at the start of the coverage period CHF 9'750'000 | Policyholders CHF 9'119'384 | Insurer's share CHF 630'616 | CSM CHF 416'576 | PV admin costs CHF 163'079 | PV death extra CHF 40'769 | RA CHF 10'192

Fund at the start of the coverage period (account values)

CHF 9'750'000

Insurer's share, enlarged

CHF 630'616
Fund at the start of the coverage period (account values) CHF 9'750'000
Insurer's share, enlarged CHF 630'616

Subsequent measurement

Analysis of change

After initial measurement, the insurer remeasures the contract group at each reporting date and allocates each change to the CSM or profit or loss.

Comparison with GMM

TopicVFAGMMMore details
Financial changes (asset returns and interest rates)The change in the insurer's share of the underlying items adjusts the CSM IFRS 17.45(b). The policyholder's share stays in the BEL.The CSM does not change IFRS 17.B97(a). The effect on the fulfilment cash flows goes to insurance finance income or expenses, in profit or loss or other comprehensive income (OCI).Market changes
Interest on the CSMThe CSM has no interest accretion at a locked-in rate. It grows with the insurer's share of the fund return.The CSM accretes interest at the locked-in rate IFRS 17.44(b). The interest adds to the CSM and is an insurance finance expense in profit or loss IFRS 17.87.Expected development
Change in non-financial assumptionsAdjusts the CSM, measured at current ratesAdjusts the CSM, measured at locked-in rates IFRS 17.B72(c)Experience and assumption changes

Allocation of changes

If an unfavourable change exceeds the CSM, the excess is a loss in profit or loss IFRS 17.48.

ChangeVFAGMMParagraph
Claims and costs of the period: actual against expectedProfit or lossProfit or lossIFRS 17.B97(c) IFRS 17.B113(a)
Premiums that relate to future service: actual against expectedCSM, at current ratesCSM, at locked-in ratesIFRS 17.B96(a) IFRS 17.B113(a)
Estimates of future non-financial cash flowsCSM, at current ratesCSM, at locked-in ratesIFRS 17.B96(b) IFRS 17.B113(a)
RA for future serviceCSM, at current ratesCSM, at locked-in ratesIFRS 17.B96(d) IFRS 17.B113(a)
Fund value: policyholder's shareBEL, with the finance expense in profit or loss or OCIBEL, with the finance expense in profit or loss or OCIIFRS 17.B111 IFRS 17.B97(a)
Fund value: insurer's shareCSMProfit or loss or OCIIFRS 17.B112 IFRS 17.B97(a)
Interest rates and guaranteesCSM, unless IFRS 17.B115 appliesProfit or loss or OCIIFRS 17.B113(b) IFRS 17.B97(a)
Incurred claims: change in estimateProfit or lossProfit or lossIFRS 17.B97(b)

Coverage units

Each year the CSM is released in proportion to the service given in the year against the service still to come.

The units measure the quantity of benefits and the expected coverage period IFRS 17.B119. For VFA contracts the service includes investment-related service. This example uses the account value plus the death cover per policy in force. Each insurer must judge its own measure and disclose its approach IFRS 17.117(c)(v) (TRG May 2018).

  • Year 1 has the most units, because it has the most policies and the largest fund
  • This example does not discount the units. IFRS 17.B119 does not mention discounting, so this is a policy choice.
  • Each year the release depends on the fund value used: The opening fund, the average fund, or the fund before the year's payouts. This example uses the opening fund. The choice has the largest effect in year 3, when the fund falls 10%: 75'038 / 72'629 / 70'118.

The year-1 units are the fund of CHF 9'750'000 plus 1'000 × 1'000 policies, a total of 10'750'000. The future units for year 1 are the sum of years 2 to 5 in the table Year 1: cash flows on the closing basis (step 5). Year 5 releases the whole remaining CSM, because no future units remain.

The full five-year coverage-unit and CSM release schedule is in Full valuation.

Expected development

The first year applies the analysis of change with experience as expected. At year-end, the insurer revalues the BEL and RA and adjusts the CSM for its share of the fund return.

The order of the analysis of change

The analysis of change splits the movement from opening to closing balance into steps. Each step changes one input. IFRS 17 sets no order for the steps. This example uses the order below in every year. In year 1 steps 2 to 5 are zero, because year 1 goes exactly as assumed. The figure below gives amounts in CHF, with k for thousand and m for million.

BEL in year 1

Opening CHF 9'323'232 | Step 1 Time CHF 279'696 | Step 2 Fund return CHF 0 | Step 3 Rates CHF 0 | Step 4 Experience CHF 0 | Step 5 Assumptions CHF 0 | Paid out CHF −643'512 | Closing CHF 8'959'416

  1. Opening9.32m
  2. Step 1Time+280k
  3. Step 2Fund return0
  4. Step 3Rates0
  5. Step 4Experience0
  6. Step 5Assumptions0
  7. Paid out−644k
  8. Closing8.96m
#StepWhat changesBEL, CHF
0OpeningLast year-end basis. Year 1: the BEL at the start of the coverage period (d in Initial measurement)9'323'232
1TimeUnwind one year at the opening rate of 3%279'696
2Fund returnActual fund return instead of the assumed one–
3RatesNew discount rate and assumed return–
4ExperienceActual deaths and surrenders–
5AssumptionsNew best estimates for future years–
Paid outBenefits and costs paid at the year-end−643'512
ClosingBEL at the end of year 18'959'416

CSM growth from the fund return

Under the GMM, the CSM earns interest at the rate locked in at the start of the coverage period IFRS 17.44(b). The VFA has no interest accretion line. Instead, the CSM grows with the insurer's share of the fund return. This share is the full fund return minus the unwind of the BEL and RA (step 1 in the figure above).

In year 1 the VFA amount and the GMM interest at the locked-in 3% are almost the same. In later years the VFA amount follows the current rate and the actual fund. In years 4 and 5 the rate is 2%, so the VFA amount is lower.

Time-value change in the CSM under the VFA
Line itemYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
aExpected return on the fundOpening fund × opening rate292'500278'951250'463134'702123'155
bBEL unwindFull valuation, step 1 − step 0−279'696−268'785−243'548−132'275−121'982
cRA unwindFull valuation, step 1 − step 0−306−240−162−70−33
dChange in VFA CSM from time valuea + b + c12'4989'9266'7532'3571'140
eOpening VFA CSMCSM column in the reconciliation by measurement component416'576334'696230'486117'19857'087
fImplied rate on the CSMd ÷ e3.00%2.97%2.93%2.01%2.00%

Experience and assumption changes

After the expected first year, more policyholders die and surrender than expected in year 2. The insurer also raises its surrender assumption for future years.

Events in year 2

In year 2, more policyholders leave than expected. The insurer changes the surrender assumption for years 3 and 4 from 5% to 8%.

Year 2: Expected and actual
Line itemHow it is calculatedExpectedActualDifference
aPolicies in force at start of year 2Actual end of year 1 (Full valuation, year 1)940.00940.00–
bDeathsExpected 1%, actual 1.5% of a9.4014.104.70
cSurrendersExpected 5%, actual 10% of a47.0094.0047.00
dPolicies in force at end of year 2a − b − c883.60831.90−51.70
eDeath extra paid (insurance part)b × 1'0009'40014'1004'700
fAccount values paid (investment part)(b + c) × account value at year-end566'0181'084'869518'851
gAdministration costsa × 4037'60037'600–

Allocation of each change

Past and current service go to profit or loss. Future service goes to the CSM. The investment component itself does not go to insurance revenue or insurance service expenses (TRG April 2019).

In the analysis of change, the profit or loss on each line is the return on the fund minus the change in the liability. The fund return is investment income. It goes to profit or loss because the insurer holds the fund at fair value. Rows e in Year 2 change to g in Year 2 change are the changes in year 2. The other rows occur every year.

Under the GMM, the insurer measures the CSM adjustments at the locked-in rate. In year 2 both rates are 3%, so the GMM gives the same amounts for the lost fees and the fixed cash flows.

VFA analysis of change in year 2
Line itemReturn on fundBELRACSMLiabilityProfit
aOpening balanceClosing balance of year 18'959'4167'998334'6969'302'110
bTime value at the opening rateFund: opening fund × opening rate. BEL and RA: unwind. CSM: fund − BEL − RA278'951268'7852409'926278'951–
cMarket: fund return differs from expectedFund: actual − expected return. BEL: revalue with actual fund. CSM: fund − BEL––––––
dMarket: interest rate changeBEL and RA at the new rate. CSM: −(BEL + RA)––––––
eClaims experience this year (death extra)Actual − expected death-extra payments–4'700––4'700−4'700
fActual deaths and surrenders: effect on future yearsBEL and RA for future years with the actual policies. The fund and the BEL fall together for the account values paid IFRS 17.B111. CSM: −(BEL + RA)–14'770−344−14'426––
gAssumption change for future yearsBEL and RA on the new assumption. CSM: −(BEL + RA)–7'155−165−6'990––
hRA release for this yearRA on this year's death-extra and costs––−2'350–−2'3502'350
iCSM release for this yearCSM before release × coverage units this year ÷ all remaining coverage units–––−92'720−92'72092'720
jCash paid at year-endActual benefits and costs paid. No profit effect−1'136'569−1'136'569
kClosing balance and totals for the yearSum of a to j278'9518'118'2575'379230'4868'354'12290'370

Market changes

After the experience and assumption changes in year 2, the fund falls 10% in year 3 instead of rising 3%. At year-end, the risk-free rate falls from 3% to 2%.

Market movement in year 3

Year 3: Market movement
Line itemHow it is calculatedExpectedActualDifference
aOpening fundClosing fund of year 28'348'7728'348'772–
bFund return rateExpected at the opening rate. Actual: market fall3%−10%
cFund returna × b250'463−834'877−1'085'340
dRisk-free rate at the end of year 3Used for discounting and for expected future returns3%2%
eAMC the insurer receives in year 31.5% of the fund after the return128'989112'708−16'281

CSM adjustment for the insurer's share

The policyholders carry most of the fall through their account values. The BEL changes with the fund. The insurer's AMC is 1.5% of the fund, so a smaller fund earns it a smaller AMC. That loss is the change in the variable fee, and it adjusts the CSM instead of profit or loss IFRS 17.45(b) IFRS 17.45(c). The figure below gives amounts in CHF thousand (k).

ΔCSMfin=Fund return−ΔBELfin−ΔRAfin

Δ is the change in the year. “fin” is the part caused by financial changes: The fund return and interest rates.

  • Expected part: 250'463 − 243'548 − 162 = 6'753 (row b in Year 3 change). This happens every year.
  • Market part: −1'085'340 − (−1'041'387 + 1'000) − 50 = −45'003 (rows c in Year 3 change and d in Year 3 change). Of this, −43'953 is the insurer's share of the fund change and −1'050 is the rate effect on fixed cash flows IFRS 17.B113(b).
  • The rate cut moves the BEL by only CHF 1'000, because only the fixed cash flows depend on the rate
CSM roll-forward in year 3

Opening CHF 230'486 | Variable fee time value CHF 6'753 | Variable fee market change CHF −45'003 | Release to profit CHF −75'038 | Closing CHF 117'198

  1. Opening230k
  2. Variable feetime value+6'753
  3. Variable feemarket change−45k
  4. Release toprofit−75k
  5. Closing117k
VFA analysis of change in year 3
Line itemReturn on fundBELRACSMLiabilityProfit
aOpening balanceClosing balance of year 28'118'2575'379230'4868'354'122
bTime value at the opening rateFund: opening fund × opening rate. BEL and RA: unwind. CSM: fund − BEL − RA250'463243'5481626'753250'463–
cMarket: fund return differs from expectedFund: actual − expected return. BEL: revalue with actual fund. CSM: fund − BEL−1'085'340−1'041'387–−43'953−1'085'340–
dMarket: interest rate changeBEL and RA at the new rate. CSM: −(BEL + RA)–1'00050−1'050––
eClaims experience this year (death extra)Actual − expected death-extra payments––––––
fActual deaths and surrenders: effect on future yearsBEL and RA for future years with the actual policies. The fund and the BEL fall together for the account values paid IFRS 17.B111. CSM: −(BEL + RA)––––––
gAssumption change for future yearsBEL and RA on the new assumption. CSM: −(BEL + RA)––––––
hRA release for this yearRA on this year's death-extra and costs––−2'080–−2'0802'080
iCSM release for this yearCSM before release × coverage units this year ÷ all remaining coverage units–––−75'038−75'03875'038
jCash paid at year-endActual benefits and costs paid. No profit effect−707'702−707'702
kClosing balance and totals for the yearSum of a to j−834'8776'613'7163'511117'1986'734'42577'118

Reporting

Presentation and disclosure

The insurer reports the measurement changes in the income statement, balance sheet and notes. The following statements cover all five years of the example.

Finance income and expenses

TopicVFAGMMMore details
Insurance finance expenseEquals the change in fair value of the underlying items.Unwind at the current rate, accretion at the locked-in rate, financial changes.Expected development
OCI optionIf the insurer holds the underlying items, the OCI option uses the current-period book yield IFRS 17.B134. If not, it uses a systematic allocation IFRS 17.B131–B133.The options are in IFRS 17.B131 IFRS 17.B132. These contracts have cash flows that vary with returns, so B132 applies: The insurer uses a systematic allocation.Not used here

Income statement

The insurance service result comes from the CSM release, the RA release and claims experience. Investment income comes from the fund assets under IFRS 9. Only the insurance finance expense comes from IFRS 17. The net financial result is a subtotal of the two, and under the VFA it is zero. The account values paid on death, surrender and maturity are investment components, so revenue excludes them IFRS 17.85. The AMC reaches profit through the CSM release.

Income statement under the VFA
Line itemYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Total
Insurance revenue
aExpected death-extra claimsExpected deaths × 1'000 (investment part excluded)10'0009'4008'3197'5706'88942'178
bExpected administration costsExpected policies × 4040'00037'60033'27630'28127'556168'713
cRA releaseRow h of the analysis of change2'5002'3502'0801'8921'72210'544
dCSM releaseRow i of the analysis of change94'37892'72075'03862'46858'227382'831
eRecovery of acquisition cash flows250'000 ÷ 5 years IFRS 17.B12550'00050'00050'00050'00050'000250'000
fInsurance revenuea + b + c + d + e IFRS 17.B124196'878192'070168'713152'211144'394854'266
Insurance service expenses
gDeath-extra claims incurredActual deaths × 1'000−10'000−14'100−8'319−7'570−6'889−46'878
hAdministration costs incurredActual policies × 40−40'000−37'600−33'276−30'281−27'556−168'713
iAmortisation of acquisition cash flowsSame as e−50'000−50'000−50'000−50'000−50'000−250'000
jInsurance service expensesg + h + i−100'000−101'700−91'595−87'851−84'445−465'591
kInsurance service resultf + j96'87890'37077'11864'36059'949388'675
lInvestment income on the fund (IFRS 9 line item)Actual fund return292'500278'951−834'877134'702123'155−5'569
mInsurance finance expense−l−292'500−278'951834'877−134'702−123'1555'569
nNet financial resultl + m––––––
oProfit for the yeark + n96'87890'37077'11864'36059'949388'675

Balance sheet

The insurer's own cash earns no interest in this example. All benefits are paid at year-end, so the balance sheet has no liability for incurred claims at any date.

Reconciliation by measurement component

The standard requires a reconciliation of the BEL, RA and CSM from opening to closing balance IFRS 17.101. The CSM is one column of this note. In each year, the changes in estimates (c in Year 1 reconciliation) net to zero in the total column: The change in the variable fee moves from the BEL and the RA to the CSM. The total insurance finance expense (g in Year 1 reconciliation) equals the expense in the income statement. This example splits the RA change into a service part and a finance part. The standard makes that split optional IFRS 17.81. Select a year.

Reconciliation by measurement component, year 1
Line itemHow it is calculatedBELRACSMTotal
aOpening balanceNo contracts before initial recognition––––
Changes that relate to future service
bContracts recognised in the yearBEL: d in Initial measurement − c in Initial measurement. RA and CSM: e in Initial measurement and g in Initial measurement−426'76810'192416'576–
cChanges in estimates that adjust the CSMCSM: Analysis of change, CSM column. BEL and RA: the opposite amounts−12'498–12'498–
Changes that relate to current service
dCSM recognised for services providede in Coverage units––−94'378−94'378
eRelease of the RAAnalysis of change row h–−2'500–−2'500
fExperience adjustmentsAnalysis of change row e––––
Finance and cash
gInsurance finance expenseTotal = change in fair value of the fund IFRS 17.87 IFRS 17.B128(c)292'194306–292'500
hPremiums receiveda in Cash flows10'000'000––10'000'000
iAcquisition cash flows paidb in Cash flows−250'000––−250'000
jBenefits paid, including account valuesActual death, surrender and maturity payments−603'512––−603'512
kAdministration costs paidActual costs−40'000––−40'000
lClosing balanceSum of the rows above. Equals the balance sheet8'959'4167'998334'6969'302'110

Disclosures

These apply to unit-linked, with-profits and variable annuity contracts alike.

  • The composition and fair value of the underlying items IFRS 17.111
  • If the insurer uses the risk mitigation option, the effect on the CSM in the period IFRS 17.112
  • Sensitivity of profit or loss and equity to market moves IFRS 17.128. A CSM sensitivity is voluntary. IFRS 17.129 allows a different sensitivity method if the insurer uses it to manage risk.
  • Presentation: If the insurer holds the underlying items, the OCI option uses the current-period book yield IFRS 17.B134. If not, it uses a systematic allocation IFRS 17.B131–B133. Amounts under the risk mitigation option stay in profit or loss IFRS 17.87A IFRS 17.B117A. Expected guarantee top-ups enter insurance revenue unless they are investment components IFRS 17.B124(a).

Key performance indicators

At initial recognition the new business CSM is CHF 416'576 (row g in Initial measurement). This is a new business margin of 4.17% of premiums. The lifetime profit is CHF 388'675.

Key figures by year
Line itemYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
Business volume
aFund under management at year-enda in Balance sheet9'298'3508'348'7726'735'0806'157'729–
bAMC earnedActual AMC150'638143'660112'708103'04794'213
cAMC marginb ÷ opening fund1.55%1.55%1.35%1.53%1.53%
CSM and profit
dCSM releasee in Coverage units94'37892'72075'03862'46858'227
eEconomic variance absorbed by the CSMAnalysis of change rows c and d, CSM column––−45'003––
fOperating variance (experience in profit)−Analysis of change row e–−4'700–––
gProfito in Income statement96'87890'37077'11864'36059'949
hClosing CSMClosing CSM in the reconciliation by measurement component334'696230'486117'19857'087–

Products

Participating products

Unit-linked, most with-profits and many variable annuities pay out from a specific pool of assets, so they usually qualify for the VFA (see Scope and recognition).

Product comparison

In the table, “usual” means the common outcome. The insurer must still test each contract against IFRS 17.B101.

Products compared
ProductUnderlying itemsUsual model and whyEffect of a market fall on the CSMNeeds many scenarios?
Unit-linkedThe unit fundVFA: The fund is the pool, and the insurer takes a fee from it.Falls by the lost future annual management charges (about 15% of the CSM in the unit-linked example).No, if there are no guarantees
With-profitsThe with-profits poolUsually VFA: The with-profits fund is the pool. Test each contract once, at inception of the contract IFRS 17.B102.Falls by the lost charges. If shareholders bear the guarantee, it also falls by the higher guarantee cost and can be used up.Yes
Variable annuity with guaranteesThe funds the policyholder choosesVFA if condition (c) is met. The VFA allows a guarantee, but a large guarantee can fail condition (c).Falls by the lost fees and the higher guarantee cost, and can be used up. If the insurer hedges, it can use the risk mitigation option IFRS 17.B115.Yes
Traditional life with profit participationA portfolio of the insurer's assets, with a legal or contractual minimum shareVFA or GMM. Apply the test in Scope and recognition.If VFA: Falls by the insurer's share of the loss, plus any guarantee cost.Yes, for the interest guarantee
Universal lifeNone. The insurer sets a crediting rateGMM, because there is no clearly identified pool.Financial changes go to insurance finance income or expenses. Discretionary changes adjust the CSM IFRS 17.B98–B100.If there is a minimum rate
Investment contract with discretionary participationThe pool the bonuses come fromVFA if it passes the VFA test, otherwise GMM. The test is written for insurance contracts, so applying it here needs judgement. IFRS 17.71 adds a few special rules for these contracts.Depends on the model chosen.Often, for the guaranteed rate
Term life, annuities in paymentNoneGMM, or the premium allocation approach (PAA) if eligible, because there is no participation.Rate changes go to insurance finance income or expenses.No
Reinsurance issued or heldNoneGMM or PAA, because IFRS 17.B109 excludes these contracts from the VFA.The VFA does not apply.Depends on the contract

Inputs by product

InputUnit-linkedWith-profitsVariable annuity
Underlying itemsThe unit fundThe with-profits poolThe funds the policyholder chooses
Insurer's shareThe annual management charge (AMC)1/9 of each bonus and the guarantee chargeThe fund charge and the guarantee charge
Cash flows that do not vary with the itemsDeath extra and costsCosts and the guarantee costCosts and the guarantee cost
Projections neededOneMany scenariosMany scenarios, or a closed-form value for a simple guarantee
Coverage unitsAccount value plus death coverA judgement to discloseA judgement to disclose. One option is the higher of the account value and the guaranteed amount.

Guarantees IFRS 17.B113(b) and the risk mitigation option IFRS 17.B115 change the result by product. With a guarantee, a market fall makes a group onerous more easily.

Product-specific accounting

  • Hedging: If the insurer hedges a guarantee with derivatives, it can choose the risk mitigation option IFRS 17.B115. The effect of the hedged risk then goes to profit or loss (see variable annuity).

Each product page has sections called “Initial measurement” and “Subsequent measurement” that list these points for that product.

Reference

Full valuation

The full valuation records each step of the example, the CSM release schedule and the valuation, closing cash flows and analysis of change for all five years.

FAQ

Measurement

Reporting

Glossary

Show the 17 terms
TermMeaning
AMCAnnual management charge. A percentage of the fund that the insurer takes each year.
BELBest estimate liability. This term is not in IFRS 17. The standard uses “estimates of the present value of the future cash flows” IFRS 17.101(a).
Coverage unitsThe quantity of service in each period. They set how fast the CSM is released.
CSMContractual service margin. The profit not yet earned.
FCFFulfilment cash flows. BEL plus RA.
GMMGeneral measurement model. The default IFRS 17 model.
Guarantee costThe average top-up the insurer pays when the guarantee is above the asset share or account value. This is the value of the guarantee: Intrinsic value plus time value.
Investment componentThe amount paid to the policyholder in all cases. Excluded from revenue and expenses.
Loss componentThe part of the liability that tracks losses on an onerous group.
OCIOther comprehensive income. The insurer can choose to present part of the insurance finance income or expenses there IFRS 17.88(b).
OnerousA group of contracts is onerous when it is expected to make a loss. The insurer recognises the loss in profit or loss at once IFRS 17.47 IFRS 17.48.
PVPresent value. A future amount discounted to today.
RARisk adjustment for non-financial risk.
Risk mitigation optionThe choice in IFRS 17.B115 to take hedged financial changes in the guarantee cost, or in the insurer's share of the items, to profit or loss instead of the CSM.
Risk-neutralA projection where every asset is expected to earn the risk-free rate.
Underlying itemsThe items that determine some of the amounts payable to a policyholder. They can be any items. Here, the fund or the pool.
VFAVariable fee approach. The IFRS 17 model for contracts with direct participation features.

Sources