Reinsurance held

Non-proportional reinsurance

Per-risk excess of loss, stop loss and mass lapse reinsurance

What is non-proportional reinsurance?

In a non-proportional treaty, the reinsurer pays only the amount above an agreed point, up to a limit. A per-risk excess of loss applies this to each single claim. A stop loss applies it to the total claims for the year. Mass lapse reinsurance works like a stop loss on lapses instead of claims.

Per-risk excess of loss

The reinsurer pays the part of each single claim above a retention, up to a limit.

How it works

  • In the example, the expected claims of 100 are three claims of 10, 30 and 60. A layer of 20 above 20, meaning a retention of 20 and a limit of 20, pays 0, 10 and 20, so 30 in total
  • That is the same 30 as the quota share, but all of it comes from the two larger claims
Claims split at the retention and limitCedant's shareReinsurer's share
Claim 10Claim 30Claim 60
0 of 10
10 of 30
20 of 60
Recovery per claim=min⁡(max⁡(claim−retention,0),limit)\text{Recovery per claim} = \min\big(\max(\text{claim} - \text{retention}, 0), \text{limit}\big)
More details
ItemDetail
CoversEach single claim between the retention and the retention + limit
RecoveryDepends on the size of each claim
PremiumA rate on the subject premium of the cedant, such as its gross net premium income (GNPI), paid in advance
Commission or allowanceUsually none
TermUsually one year
Recovery per claim=min⁡(max⁡(claim−retention,0),limit)Expected recovery=∑expected recovery per claimPremium=expected recovery+expenses+risk load\begin{aligned} \text{Recovery per claim} &= \min\big(\max(\text{claim} - \text{retention}, 0), \text{limit}\big) \\[0.4em] \text{Expected recovery} &= \textstyle\sum \text{expected recovery per claim} \\[0.4em] \text{Premium} &= \text{expected recovery} + \text{expenses} + \text{risk load} \end{aligned}

Cash flows

Large claims take time to settle. In the example, 40% of the recoveries are paid in year 1 and 60% in year 2. The premium of 33 is paid in advance.

YearPremium paidRecoveries receivedNet cash flow to the cedant
133
2–18
Total3330−3

Pricing

The reinsurer estimates the expected loss in the layer from restated past claims (experience rating), from the risk profile (exposure rating), or both. It adds the time value of money, expenses and a risk load (Clark 1996). The premium is usually a rate on the subject premium, which is the premium the cedant collects on the covered business. In the example, the premium of 33 is the expected recovery of 30 plus a loading of 3, which is 33 ÷ 90 = 36.7% of the subject premium of 90.

IFRS 17

ItemTreatment
ScopeIn scope if the risk transfer is significantIFRS 17.B18–B19
Measurement modelGeneral model, or PAA if eligibleIFRS 17.69. One-year cover is eligible, but the PAA is optional
Commission or allowanceUsually none
Contract boundaryUsually one year
Watch out forLarge claims settle slowly, so discount the recoveriesIFRS 17.36

How is the recovery % calculated?

The recovery % is the share of the underlying claims that the reinsurer is expected to pay. The LoRC is the underlying loss × the recovery %.

Recovery %=expected recoveriesexpected claims of the underlying contract group\text{Recovery \%} = \dfrac{\text{expected recoveries}}{\text{expected claims of the underlying contract group}}

In the example, the recovery % = 30 ÷ (10 + 30 + 60) = 30%, so the LoRC = 20 × 30% = 6.

Stop loss

The reinsurer pays the part of the total claims for a year above an attachment point, up to a limit. The attachment point works like the retention of an excess of loss, but on the total for the year.

How it works

  • In the example, the total claims are 60, 100 or 160, with probabilities of 30%, 50% and 20%, so the expected claims are 100. A layer of 50 above 110 pays only in the bad year, so the expected recovery = 20% × 50 = 10
  • Apply the layer in each scenario, then weight the results by probability. Applied to the expected claims of 100, the layer would pay 0
Total claims by scenarioCedant's shareReinsurer's share
Probability 30%Probability 50%Probability 20%
0 of 60
0 of 100
50 of 160
ScenarioProbabilityTotal claimsRecoveryProbability × recovery
Good year30%6000
Normal year50%10000
Bad year20%1605010
Expected100%10010
More details
ItemDetail
CoversThe total claims for a year between the attachment point and the attachment point + limit
RecoveryThe part of the total above the attachment point
PremiumA fixed amount, paid in advance
Commission or allowanceNone
TermUsually one year
Recovery(s)=min⁡(max⁡(total claims(s)−attachment point,0),limit)Expected recovery=∑sprobability(s)×recovery(s)Premium=expected recovery+expenses+risk load\begin{aligned} \text{Recovery}(s) &= \min\big(\max(\text{total claims}(s) - \text{attachment point}, 0), \text{limit}\big) \\[0.4em] \text{Expected recovery} &= \textstyle\sum_s \text{probability}(s) \times \text{recovery}(s) \\[0.4em] \text{Premium} &= \text{expected recovery} + \text{expenses} + \text{risk load} \end{aligned}

Here s is a claims scenario. A stop loss pays only above the attachment point, so apply the formula in each scenario and weight the results by probability.

Cash flows

The total claims for the year are known only after the year end, so the recovery is paid in year 2. The premium of 12 is paid at the start of the year.

YearPremium paidExpected recoveriesNet cash flow to the cedant
112–−12
2–1010
Total1210−2

Pricing

The reinsurer models total claims with an aggregate model and adds loadings for expenses and risk (Clark 1996). In the example, the premium of 12 is the expected recovery of 10 plus a loading of 2.

IFRS 17

ItemTreatment
ScopeIn scope if the risk transfer is significantIFRS 17.B18–B19
Measurement modelGeneral model, or PAA if eligibleIFRS 17.69. One-year cover is eligible, but the PAA is optional
Commission or allowanceNone
Contract boundaryUsually one year
Watch out forWeight the recovery in each scenario by its probabilityIFRS 17.B38–B39. The LoRC cap can apply after claims increase (see Cap and release)

How is the recovery % calculated?

The recovery % is the share of the underlying claims that the reinsurer is expected to pay. The LoRC is the underlying loss × the recovery %.

Recovery %=expected recoveriesexpected claims of the underlying contract group\text{Recovery \%} = \dfrac{\text{expected recoveries}}{\text{expected claims of the underlying contract group}}

In the example, the recovery % = 10 ÷ 100 = 10%, so the LoRC = 20 × 10% = 2.

What happens at the next reporting date?

At each reporting date, the LoRC can be at most the underlying loss component × the current recovery %. When the estimates change, this cap can fall below the LoRC, and the cedant then reduces the LoRC to the cap.

  • The bad year becomes more likely, 30% instead of 20%. The expected claims rise to 110, so the loss component rises to 30, and the expected recoveries rise to 15. The increase of 5 goes to profit or loss and takes the LoRC from 2 to 7IFRS 17.66(c)(i)
  • The cap = loss component × new recovery % = 30 × (15 ÷ 110) = 30 × 13.6% = 4.09IFRS 17.B119F. So the cedant takes 2.91 of the 7 off the LoRC against the held CSMIFRS 17.66(bb)
The stop loss LoRC after one period

Opening LoRC 2 rises by 5 to 7 before the cap. A reduction of 2.91 brings closing LoRC to 4.09.

  1. OpeningLoRC2
  2. Recoveriesup 10 → 15+5
  3. Beforethe cap7
  4. Cap(66(bb))−2.91
  5. ClosingLoRC4.09
Example: The stop loss LoRC

The underlying contract group has a loss component of 20.

  • Recovery % = expected recoveries ÷ expected claims = 10 ÷ 100 = 10%
  • Loss-recovery income = 20 × 10% = 2
  • Applying the recovery formula to the expected claims of 100 instead would give 0
Example: The stop loss after one period

The bad year becomes more likely: 30% instead of 20%, and the good year 20% instead of 30%.

ScenarioProbabilityTotal claimsRecoveryProbability × claimsProbability × recovery
Good year20%600120
Normal year50%1000500
Bad year30%160504815
Expected100%11015
  • New recovery % = 15 ÷ 110 = 13.6%
  • Increase in expected claims = 110 − 100 = 10
  • The whole increase in expected claims goes to the underlying loss component, so it becomes 20 + 10 = 30
  • Increase in expected recoveries = 15 − 10 = 5, in profit or lossIFRS 17.66(c)(i)
  • LoRC before the cap = 2 + 5 = 7
  • Cap = 30 × 15 ÷ 110 = 4.09IFRS 17.B119F
  • LoRC = 4.09. The excess of 2.91 is an expense in profit or loss, and the net-cost CSM decreases by 2.91IFRS 17.66(bb)
  • Net income in profit or loss = 5 − 2.91 = 2.09

After the premium of 12 is paid, the held asset is the expected recoveries of 10 plus the net-cost CSM of 2 + 2 = 4, so 14. The LoRC of 2 is part of it.

MovementARC excluding LoRCLoRCTotal
Opening balance12.002.0014.00
Recovery of losses: recoveries 10 → 15IFRS 17.66(c)(i)–5.005.00
Cap of 30 × 15 ÷ 110 = 4.09: CSM adjustmentIFRS 17.66(bb)–(2.91)(2.91)
Closing balance12.004.0916.09

Estimates for a real portfolio

For a real portfolio, three methods give an estimate without a full stochastic modelIFRS 17.B38–B39:

  • Fitted distribution: Calculate the mean and variance of total claims from mortality and sums at risk. Fit a normal or lognormal distribution and calculate the expected layer payment
  • Burning cost: Restate past years of total claims to today's exposure. Apply the treaty to each year and take the average
  • Reinsurer's pricing: Use the expected loss cost of the layer from the reinsurer as a cross-check

Mass lapse reinsurance

A lapse is a policyholder canceling a policy before it ends. A mass lapse is when many policyholders do this in the same year, and the cedant loses the future profit on those policies. Mass lapse reinsurance works like a stop loss on lapses. When the lapse rate in a year exceeds an attachment point, the reinsurer pays for the lost profit.

How it works

In the example, the cover is on 10'000 policies and pays 0.2 for each lapse between a lapse rate of 20% and 50%. For most other treaties, the premium is close to the expected recoveries. Cedants buy mass lapse cover mainly for capital relief, so its premium of 15 is almost double the expected recoveries of 8. Most of the difference pays for the reinsurer's capital.

Parts of the stop loss premium

Premium 15 consists of expected recoveries 8, cost of capital 6, and expenses 1.

  1. Expectedrecoveries8
  2. Cost ofcapital+6
  3. Expenses+1
  4. Premium15
Part of the premiumCalculationAmount
Expected recoveriesWeighted over the lapse scenarios8.0
Cost of capitalCapital 150 × 4%6.0
ExpensesAssumption1.0
Premium2.5% rate on line × limit of 60015.0
More details
ItemDetail
CoversThe lapses in a treaty year between the attachment rate and the limit rate
RecoveryExcess lapses × an agreed loss per lapse. The loss per lapse is a table in the treaty, often by policy year, that approximates the lost profit or the unrecovered acquisition cost
PremiumA rate on line, which is a percentage of the limit, paid in advance
Commission or allowanceNone
TermShort, often one or two years
Excess lapses(s)=in force×max⁡(0,min⁡(lapse rate(s),limit rate)−attachment rate)Recovery(s)=excess lapses(s)×loss per lapseExpected recovery=∑sprobability(s)×recovery(s)Premium=rate on line×limit\begin{aligned} \text{Excess lapses}(s) &= \text{in force} \times \max\big(0, \min(\text{lapse rate}(s), \text{limit rate}) - \text{attachment rate}\big) \\[0.4em] \text{Recovery}(s) &= \text{excess lapses}(s) \times \text{loss per lapse} \\[0.4em] \text{Expected recovery} &= \textstyle\sum_s \text{probability}(s) \times \text{recovery}(s) \\[0.4em] \text{Premium} &= \text{rate on line} \times \text{limit} \end{aligned}

Here s is a lapse scenario. As for a stop loss, apply the formula in each scenario and weight the results by probability.

Scenarios and cash flows

The cover is on 10'000 policies. The attachment point is a lapse rate of 20%, the limit is a lapse rate of 50% and the loss per lapse is 0.2.

ScenarioProbabilityLapse rateExcess lapsesRecoveryProbability × recovery
Normal97.0%8%000
Stress2.5%30%
Extreme0.5%60%
Expected100%8.0

The premium of 15.0 is paid at the start of the year. The lapse rate for the year is known only after the year end, so the recovery is paid in year 2.

YearPremium paidExpected recoveriesNet cash flow to the cedant
115.0–−15.0
2–8.08.0
Total15.08.0−7.0

Pricing

When the treaty is written, a mass lapse is unlikely, so the expected recoveries are small (Milliman 2021). The price is a rate on line (Gallagher Re) and rises sharply as the attachment point falls. The Solvency II mass lapse stress is 40% (EIOPA 2025), and treaties attach at or below that level. The example attaches at 20%. Cedants compare the price with the capital that the cover releases. One presentation gives an equivalent cost of capital of 0.7% to 2.5% (Gallagher Re). The 2.5% in the example is the rate on line, which measures something else.

The reinsurer's premium covers the expected recoveries, its expenses and a return on capital for the tail event (Clark 1996, section 6). Illustrative assumptions:

The limit is the extreme-scenario recovery of 600, so the rate on line is 15.0 ÷ 600 = 2.5%. Only 8.0 of the premium pays for expected recoveries. The rest pays for capital and expenses.

IFRS 17

ItemTreatment
ScopeUsually reinsurance heldIFRS 17.B15. A cover that pays a fixed amount per lapse, with no link to the actual loss, can be a derivative under IFRS 9
Measurement modelGeneral model, or PAA if eligible (69)
Commission or allowanceNone
Contract boundaryUsually the treaty term (34)
Watch out forThe risk adjustment is large compared with the expected recoveries, because the value of the cover lies in rare extreme years. Project the premiums per scenario if they depend on the business in force

How is the recovery % calculated?

The recovery % is the share of the underlying claims that the reinsurer is expected to pay. The LoRC is the underlying loss × the recovery %.

Recovery %=expected recoveriesexpected claims of the underlying contract group\text{Recovery \%} = \dfrac{\text{expected recoveries}}{\text{expected claims of the underlying contract group}}

In the example, the treaty recovers no claims, so the recovery % = 0 ÷ 100 = 0% and the contract group gets no LoRC from itIFRS 17.B119D.

A change in the expected recoveries is treated the same way even without an initial LoRCIFRS 17.66(c)(i). If a change in lapse assumptions goes to the underlying loss component and also changes the expected recoveries, the change on the reinsurance held goes to profit or loss too, which reduces volatility. The standard then requires a LoRCIFRS 17.66B within the capIFRS 17.B119F. It is unresolved how that cap works with a recovery % of 0%.

Comparison

The three treaties differ in what triggers a payment, and so in the recovery % for the LoRC.

ItemPer-risk excess of lossStop lossMass lapse reinsurance
Pays forEach single claim above a retentionTotal claims above an attachment pointExcess lapses × loss per lapse
Expected recovery fromClaim sizes and numbersClaims scenariosLapse scenarios
ScopeReinsurance held, if the risk transfer is significantReinsurance held, if the risk transfer is significantUsually reinsurance held
Recovery %IFRS 17.B119D30% in the example10% in the example0%, because the cover recovers no claims
Initial LoRC on an onerous contract groupLoss component × recovery %: 6Loss component × recovery %: 2None
Later changesIFRS 17.66(c)(i)ApplyApplyApply, but the LoRCIFRS 17.66B is unresolved