Longevity swaps
Swaps that protect the cedant against policyholders living longer than expected
What is a longevity swap?
An annuity pays a pension for as long as the policyholder lives. A longevity swap protects the cedant against policyholders living longer than expected. The guide's main example has no annuities, so this page has a separate example with 1'000 policyholders.
Longevity swap
How it works
The cedant pays the reinsurer a fixed schedule of expected pensions plus a fee. In return, the reinsurer pays the actual pensions, so it takes the risk that policyholders live longer. This works like a financial swap, such as an interest rate swap, where one side pays a fixed leg and the other pays a floating leg.
- The two sides only pay the difference. If deaths follow the agreed basis, the cedant pays just the fee, 200 in year 1
- If more policyholders are alive than expected, the reinsurer pays the difference. If fewer are alive, the cedant pays more
The cedant pays pensions to policyholders and the fixed leg to the reinsurer, then receives actual pensions from the reinsurer.
| Leg in year 1 | From | To | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pensions | Cedant | Policyholders | 1'000 × 10 |
| Fixed leg | Cedant | Reinsurer | 10'000 × 1.02 |
| Floating leg | Reinsurer | Cedant | 10'000 |
| Net | Cedant | Reinsurer | 200 |
In year 1, all 1'000 policyholders are alive, so the actual pensions match the expected ones. From year 2 on, the number alive can differ from the expected number, and the net settlement can go either way. Below is year 3, where 968.3 policyholders are expected to be alive.
Cedant pays 194 when 968.3 policyholders are alive as expected, reinsurer pays 23 when 990 are alive, and cedant pays 377 when 950 are alive.
(968.3 alive)Live longer
(990 alive)Live shorter
(950 alive)
| Cash flow | As expected | Live longer | Live shorter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policyholders alive | 968.3 | 990 | 950 |
| Fixed leg: expected 9'683 + 2% fee | 9'877 | 9'877 | 9'877 |
| Floating leg: actual payments | 9'683 | 9'900 | 9'500 |
| Net settlement | Cedant pays 194 | Reinsurer pays 23 | Cedant pays 377 |
More details
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Covers | The longevity risk of named policyholders |
| Recovery | Floating leg: The actual pension payments to the policyholders who are alive |
| Premium | Fixed leg: The expected pension payments on an agreed mortality basis, plus a fee (Joint Forum 2013) |
| Commission or allowance | None. The fee is part of the fixed leg |
| Term | Typically to the death of the last policyholder, or a fixed term with a final commutation payment, depending on the treaty |
| Settlement | Only the difference between the legs is paid. Collateral is often used, based on the net payments, but deals with reinsurers may not have it (Joint Forum 2013, OSFI 2014) |
Here q(t) is the probability on the agreed basis that a policyholder dies in year t. The best estimate uses the cedant's mortality.
What does the cedant pay and receive each year?
The fixed leg for each year is the expected payment plus the 2% fee.
| Year | Expected lives | q | Expected payment | Fixed leg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1'000 | 1.5% | 1'000 × 10 | 10'000 × 1.02 |
| 2 | 1'000 × 98.5% | 1.7% | 985.0 × 10 | 9'850 × 1.02 |
| 3 | 985.0 × 98.3% | 1.9% | 968.3 × 10 | 9'683 × 1.02 |
In the example, the cedant's best estimate equals the agreed basis, so the expected floating leg equals the expected payment.
| Year | Fixed leg paid | Expected floating leg received | Expected net cash flow to the cedant |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 10'200 | 10'000 | 10'000 − 10'200 |
| 2 | 10'047 | 9'850 | 9'850 − 10'047 |
| 3 | 9'877 | 9'683 | 9'683 − 9'877 |
The expected net cash flow each year is the fee. The actual net settlement changes with the actual deaths. The pensions are paid at the start of the year to the policyholders alive at that date. In year 1, all 1'000 policyholders are alive, so the floating leg is 10'000 in every scenario. By year 3, deaths can differ from the agreed basis, as in the scenarios above.
Pricing
The fixed leg is set once, at the start, on an agreed best estimate of mortality, plus a fee for the reinsurer's risk and expenses (OSFI 2014). It stays the same when policyholders die earlier or later than expected.
Two features can change it:
- Indexation: The fixed leg usually moves with the actual index, but not with deaths
- Rebasing: Some treaties let the reinsurer reprice the agreed basis at set review dates
IFRS 17
| Item | Treatment |
|---|---|
| Scope | In scope for named policyholders. A swap on a population mortality index transfers financial risk only, so IFRS 9 usually appliesIFRS 17.B8 |
| Measurement model | General model |
| Commission or allowance | None |
| Contract boundary | Often the death of the last policyholder. A rebasing clause does not, by itself, end itIFRS 17.34 |
| Watch out for | The fixed leg is the premium and the floating leg is the recoveries. Measure both gross, even if only the difference is paid. The floating leg is the cedant's best estimate, updated at each reporting dateIFRS 17.33(a), 63 |
How is the recovery % calculated?
The recovery % is the share of the underlying claims that the reinsurer is expected to pay. The LoRC is the underlying loss × the recovery %.
For a longevity swap, the expected recoveries are the expected floating leg and the expected claims are the expected pension payments of the contract group. In the example, if the swap covers every policyholder in the contract group, the recovery % is 100%.
How does the cedant value each leg?
The fixed leg follows the schedule in the treaty, and only the floating leg is an estimate.
| Item | Fixed leg | Floating leg |
|---|---|---|
| Mortality basis | Agreed basis in the treaty | Best estimate of the cedant |
| When it is set | Once, at inception | Again at each reporting date |
| Changes with actual deaths | No | Yes |
| In the fulfilment cash flows | Contractual amounts from the schedule | Expected value, updated each period |
The agreed basis is the reinsurer's price, and the best estimate is the cedant's own view. The expected cost of the cover is the fee plus the gap between the two.
Example: Fewer deaths than the agreed basis
The swap above, but the best estimate of the cedant has q 10% lower than the agreed basis: 1.35% in year 1 and 1.53% in year 2. The fixed leg does not change.
| Year | Best estimate lives | Fixed leg paid | Expected floating leg received | Expected net cash flow to the cedant |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1'000 | 10'200 | 10'000 | 10'000 − 10'200 |
| 2 | 1'000 × 98.65% | 10'047 | 986.5 × 10 | 9'865 − 10'047 |
| 3 | 986.5 × 98.47% | 9'877 | 971.4 × 10 | 9'714 − 9'877 |
The cedant expects the policyholders to live longer than the agreed basis assumes, so it expects the swap to cost less than the fee.
At each reporting date:
- The actual net settlement replaces the expected one. The difference is an experience adjustment
- The cedant projects again from the policyholders alive. If 12 die in year 1 instead of 15, year 2 starts from 988 lives instead of 985
- A change in mortality assumptions is a change in estimates. The future-service part adjusts the held CSMIFRS 17.66(c) and largely offsets the change in the underlying annuities